Connect with us

AAMI Series

Collingwood v Richmond – AAMI Fantasy notes

Jamie’s takeaways from the Magpies v Tigers AAMI Community Series game.

Although this contest was just a pre-season hit for both clubs, there were a number of developments to come out of the game for fantasy coaches. From a team’s perspective, Collingwood appeared to want to move the ball more quickly, with fewer disposals. The Magpies have been amongst the top fantasy scoring teams in recent seasons, which could change if this game style continues.

Who’s missing: Taylor Adams, Brody Mihocek, Chris Mayne

Jordan de Goey (FWD, $605)

At $605 in fantasy classic, de Goey isn’t cheap, and this and the lack of certainty of his role sees his ownership in fantasy classic sitting at a lowly 2%. However, I dare say this will change following his performance against the Tigers. He was by far Collingwood’s most damaging player and spent the majority of his time in the midfield, racking up an impressive 125. If you can take Taylor Adams (who was interviewed at half time) at his word, de Goey’s increased midfield minutes are set to continue in the season proper.

Scott Pendlebury (MID, $805)

Just behind de Goey as Collingwood’s best, Pendles did what he has done more consistently that any other player over the last decade amassing another fantasy ton. Having never relied on pace to impact games, age seems to be a non-factor for the Magpie’s Skipper and with 124 against his name against the Tigers, he looks to be heading for another 100+ averaging season in 2021.

Jack Crisp (DEF, $726)

One of Collingwood’s best, picking up 29 disposals for 90 fantasy points. Started the game off slowly having only eight of those points at quarter time, but really came into his own after half time. At over 700k and a high break even of 97 in Round 1, even Crisp’s consistency makes it hard to look at him as a starter in classic, although will go high in draft leagues.

Brayden Sier (MID, $402)

Although, slightly disappointing in Collingwood’s scratch match against Geelong last week, Sier looked a lot better tonight. Attended plenty of centre bounces and appears at this stage Buckley is going to give him a decent opportunity to nail down a spot in their best 22. If you’re after a mid-priced player in your midfield, Sier is definitely an option on this performance.

Jeremy Howe (DEF, $669)

Considering his long lay off from the game, Howe was really solid against the Tigers scoring 76 from just 67% TOG. Can only see him getting better in coming weeks as he gains more confidence in his leg, but at this stage, even with his discount in classic is probably more a target in draft.

Isaac Quaynor (DEF, $503)

Outshone early on by John Noble (who is similar in price in classic and around the same ADP in draft), Quaynor got better as the match progressed and finished with an impressive 84. After only nine appearances in his career to date, he appears to have locked down a spot in Collingwood’s best 22 and should only improve from here on in. With a break even of only 66, Quaynor could be a mid-priced option in defence.

Draft watch: John Noble, Brayden Maynard, Josh Daicos




Who’s missing: Bachar Houli, Dion Prestia, Tom Lynch

Jayden Short (DEF, $694)

Jayden Short quite simply had a night out. Having never scored over 110 in AFL fantasy – apart from a COVID affected 100 in Round 6 against Sydney last season, Short gathered 43 disposals on his way to a mammoth 171. The Tigers obviously want the ball in his hands as often as possible and that was certainly the case tonight as he picked up disposals at will, while the new ‘standing the mark’ rule looks like it could suit him too. However, as good as Short was tonight, Richmond were missing Houli and as Cal’s Scale of Hardness will tell you, Collingwood are one the easiest teams for opposition defenders to score against.

Dustin Martin (FWD/MID, $713)

As he has done in previous seasons, Dusty spent time in both the midfield and forward lines scoring 60 from just 64% TOG. In what was in essence just a practice match, it was to be expected Martin would not impose himself as he will in the season proper. Primed for the season opener against Carlton.

Josh Caddy (MID, $506)

Once quite a relevant fantasy player, Caddy has disappeared into obscurity in recent seasons, and while his score of 125 from 27 disposals playing on a wing will more than likely be an outlier rather than a sign of things to come in 2021, he does have a break even of only 66 in Round 1, and at least deserves a nod here.

Toby Nankervis (RUCK, $556)

Nank only played 35% of the game and came off at half time, so his score of 38 was actually quite decent under the circumstances. He did have the better of Grundy while he was on the park and he has been a solid fantasy performer in the past, but he has had his injury concerns and is probably more relevant as late draft selection rather than fantasy classic.

Shai Bolton (MID/FWD $625)

Wasn’t a big night for Bolton, with just 49 points from just 16 touches. TOG can’t be used as excuse either as he spent only 15% of the match on the bench. Spent time forward and through the midfield as he did in 2021 so was just a poor night.

Kane Lambert (FWD, $598)

As is often the case with Lambert, you barely notice him during the game and his fantasy score can surprise you. At the half time break he was sitting on 57 and finished the game with a solid enough 85. Perhaps it’s this apparent invisibility during games that puts fantasy coaches off or his steep price, but whatever the reason not even Richmond fans are keen, as his ownership in fantasy classic is at zero percent.

Draft watch: Jack Graham, Nick Vlastuin, Liam Baker




  1. Avatar


    March 6, 2021 at 5:46 am

    “Roy’s Scale of Hardness”

  2. Avatar


    March 6, 2021 at 8:02 am

    Surely there’s a write up about Grundy’s performance? Probably the most fantasy relevant player who played in this game…

    • Avatar

      Ando the brain dead barfly

      March 6, 2021 at 8:14 am

      I was looking for the Grundy write up too🤔

      • Avatar


        March 6, 2021 at 9:53 am

        I personally think grundy has slowed up. His finish to 2020 was bad maybe he’s carrying something. Last 5-6 rounds last year ROB average was way higher

  3. Avatar

    Sir Fartypants

    March 6, 2021 at 8:29 am

    What about the kids? Bianco particularly??

    • Avatar


      March 6, 2021 at 9:19 am

      Didn’t play. Not going to be in round 1 calculations you wouldn’t think based on that.

    • Avatar


      March 6, 2021 at 9:19 am

      Wasnt able to watch the game last night but based on stats does look great…

      Bianco didnt play at all

      Kelly busted his collarbone

      Henry played most of the game for 27

      Ruscoe played 3 quarters or so for 26

      Martyn played a quarter for 19

      RCD played a hald for 20

      Think its fair to say that none of them aside from maybe Henry get a debut and even if he does not sure he’s worth the pick

  4. Avatar


    March 6, 2021 at 9:18 am

    Thoughts on Daicos?

    • Avatar


      March 6, 2021 at 9:20 am

      I was keen on him for a bit, but im very cold. He’s playing way too much forward. Elliot and de Goey are getting more mid time and Adams still to come back. Not great signs for another breakout

      • Avatar


        March 6, 2021 at 9:50 am

        Yes agree, I will either swap to a serong or maybe a rookie and upgrade elsewhere

  5. Avatar


    March 6, 2021 at 9:51 am

    Operation get Shorty?

Leave a Reply

More in AAMI Series