Connect with us

Players of Interest

Roy’s Best 22 for 2019 – February Edition

Roy updates his potential best 22 for the 2019 season.

  • Roy

As the countdown to the season proper reaches a month, updating my rolling 22 is the least I can do! So here you go to use as you please, whether that me be for a guide, entertaining reading or as a source of anger to get genuinely heated about, here it is.

Click here to recap the January edition.
Click here to recap the December edition.

DEFENDERS

   2018
Avg
Proj
Avg
Change

D1

Rory Laird
Rory Laird, DEF
Genuine star, who should average around the same after taking into account the Crows improvement and the return of Brodie Smith.
107.8
(20)
107

D2

Jake Lloyd
Sydney Swans, DEF
An interrupted pre-season is the only thing stopping him from being my number one.
100.1
(22)
106

D3

Lachie Whitfield
GWS Giants, DEF
Zac William’s return pushes Whitfield up to a wing where he dominated in the Finals. One of two tag candidates for the Giants without Shiel is a slight issue.
101.6
(22)
105

D4

James Sicily
Hawthorn, DEF
Will be the number one kick out guy for the Hawks and has reportedly played on at every opportunity during match simulation.
95.6
(14)
104

D5

Alex Witherden
Brisbane Lions, DEF
In career best condition and will take his share of kick ins (knows what he needs to do to register +3 from there).
88
(22)
101

D6

Kade Simpson
Carlton, DEF
Following the loss of a few key defenders this pre season, old faithful returns. Will no doubt slog it out with minimal support again to average in the 90s.
95.3
(21)
94

In the mix: Nil.

MIDFIELDERS

   2018
Avg
Proj
Avg
Change

M1

Jack Macrae
Western Bulldogs, MID
Has had a ripper pre season and deserves to remain at the mantle.
122.6
(19)
120

M2

Zach Merrett
Essendon, MID
Remains at number two despite an interrupted pre-season. There will be additional uncontested ball this year with the addition of Shiel.
101.5
(22)
117

M3

Patrick Cripps
Carlton, MID
They don’t just hand out AFLX Vice Captaincy willy nilly… Well, they probably do but Crippa is a jet and set for a career high.
109.3
(22)
115

M4

Adam Treloar
Collingwood, MID
Had an awesome pre-season following his injury interrupted double hammy silly salmon season.
108.5
(13)
115

M5

Taylor Adams
Collingwood, MID
Yes, the main source of my critics anger remains in the eight. Especially after Brodie Grundy confirmed all my thoughts on the Podcast.
95.1
(19)
115

M6

Josh Kelly
GWS Giants, MID
I do have slight concerns about a regular tag without Shiel, however, he is still a gun.
108.4
(15)
114

M7

Lachie Neale
Brisbane Lions, MID
First uninterrupted pre-season in a long time and he is playing in a midfield where snouts are born.
100.2
(22)
113

M8

Matt Crouch
Adelaide, MID
Flying under the radar and a safe pick to round out the eight in a full strength Crows midfield.
104.9
(18)
112

In the mixDayne Beams (Collingwood, MID), Stephen Coniglio (GWS Giants, MID), Seb Ross (St Kilda, MID),  Clayton Oliver (Melbourne, MID).

RUCKS

   2018
Avg
Proj
Avg
Change

R1

Brodie Grundy
Collingwood, RUC
The toe issue has knocked off two points from my projected average, that’s all, still easily number one.
120
(22)
120

R2

Max Gawm
Melbourne, RUC
A lot of talk about Gawn spending extended time forward… Thing is he has great hands and will kick a few. Still clearly top two.
111.3
(22)
104

In the mix: Justin Westhoff (Port Adelaide, RUC/FWD), Stefan Martin (Brisbane Lions, RUC), Todd Goldstein (North Melbourne, RUC).

FORWARDS

   2018
Avg
Proj
Avg
Change

F1

Patrick Dangerfield
Geelong, MID/FWD
Genuine star, easy option as the number one and set to return to 110+ average.
106.2
(21)
110

F2

Josh Dunkley
Western Bulldogs, MID/FWD
Should slot straight back into the role he dominated at the end of the season despite Libba’s return.
95.8
(19)
108

F3

Devon Smith
Essendon, MID/FWD
The security of role and tackling prowess should ensure he is in the mix for remain a top three forward.
106.6
(22)
104

F4

Tim Kelly
Geelong, MID/FWD
Will play predominately through the midfield where he dominated the back end of the season. All class.
86.8
(22)
100

F5

Sam Menegola
Geelong, MID/FWD
May get off to a slow start like last year after an interrupted pre season. Will likely finish the year in third spot however.
98.6
(22)
100

F6

Justin Westhoff
Port Adelaide, RUC/FWD
Mr Fix it will reportedly be given a green light to once again go where he likes. Fortunately for us, he likes going where the ball is.
101.9
(22)
100

In the mixToby McLean (Western Bulldogs, MID/FWD), Isaac Heeney (Sydney Swans, MID/FWD), Jack Billings (St Kilda, MID/FWD)

What do you think, has Roy got this right? What order would you have the players in? Post your thoughts in the comments.

10 Comments

10 Comments

  1. Avatar

    anth80

    February 22, 2019 at 7:06 am

    David Mundy Roy?
    Touted fur extra midfield minutes.

  2. Avatar

    Matt

    February 22, 2019 at 10:09 am

    Any source for Westhoff going wherever he likes?

  3. Avatar

    bort22

    February 22, 2019 at 4:36 pm

    Agree with defenders and rucks. For the mids i don’t think both Treloar and Adams can average that high with Beams coming in, so I’ll go for Fyfe in for Treloar and i’ll also have Brayshaw over Neale. For the forwards i’ll have Heeney edging out Westhoff as i don’t think he’ll spend as much time in the ruck/midfield.

    • Avatar

      Nathan Schultz

      February 22, 2019 at 7:27 pm

      Agreed; I have Heeney > Westhoff at this stage. I’m also waiting and seeing how the Collingwood midfield will “spread the love” amongst themselves – so they’re more upgrade targets for me at this stage.

  4. Avatar

    Luke

    February 22, 2019 at 11:53 pm

    Jacobs and t. Adams or Goldy and J. kelly

  5. Avatar

    Harpic

    February 25, 2019 at 3:39 am

    I’ve been doing some further research on Lloyd and found some interesting stats regarding his output vs quality of opponent.

    In the home and away season against top 8 teams he averaged 112 (100+ in 8 out of 11 matches, score range 87-126). Against the rest he only averaged 91 (100+ in 2 out of 11, range 67-163) *including a big outlier of 163 vs Fremantle.

    Unsurprisingly this indicates that when Sydney face weak opposition the ball spends less time in their back half and there is less points for Lloyd.

    He starts the season against three teams who missed the eight and he failed to reach 90 against last season – WB (67), ADE (89) and CARL (88).

    Food for thought…

    • Avatar

      StopTippingMyWuti

      February 27, 2019 at 11:36 pm

      Thank you for sharing these stats. Although you should’ve kept them to yourself! imagine the upper hand u would of had.

  6. Avatar

    Vigour

    February 28, 2019 at 5:51 am

    When is the website going to be fixed up to let us regenerate our leagues? Basic stuff !

    • Warnie

      Warnie

      February 28, 2019 at 7:27 am

      You have been able to regenerate your leagues for about 4 weeks now. Go create new league and hit regenerate. Check settings and hit go.

  7. Avatar

    Vigour

    February 28, 2019 at 9:04 am

    Damn, it was hidden away! Thanks man!

Leave a Reply

More in Players of Interest