Swanny’s 171: Round 5 Review

Before you start preparing for next week, it’s time to review your squad’s effort this weekend in the DT TALK Round Review. Every Sunday night when the last game finishes, jump on here and let the world know how you went!

Copy and paste the following in the comments and fill it in.

Team Name:
Round 5 Score:
League Results:
DT Studs:
DT Duds:
On the Chopping Block:
Round 5 trades:
Vent/Brag/Whatever:

Stay tuned to DT TALK this week for all of the great AFL Dream Team advice you could ever need!

348 Comments

  • Team Name:cribofkings
    Round 5 Score:1896
    League Results: wwwww
    DT Studs:danger, h-mac martin giles
    DT Duds: stanton clarke bartel goddard rioli smith buddy
    On the Chopping Block: bartel rioli carrazzo
    Round 5 trades: ablett-stanton and rohan-treloar
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: round 5 trades gave me 160,000 salary in the bank so going to pick up big guns this week to pay up for the horrid ablett trade!!!

  • Team Name:swan district
    Round 5 Score:2155
    League Results:WWWWW
    DT Studs:Dangerfield, Swan, Robinson, Martin Sidebottom Boyd Pendlebury
    DT Duds:Conca, Goddard Cox, D.Smith
    On the Chopping Block:Cox
    Round 5 trades:None unless injuries
    Vent/Brag/Whatever:

  • Team Name:PharQall
    Round 5 Score: a disgraceful 1723
    League Results: loss
    DT Studs: No One! One player got there projected…MM
    DT Duds: The whole pack, but special mention to Drummond who I traded in for a spectacular 25
    On the Chopping Block: balla, Conigs
    Round 5 trades: considering Conigs to the horse in prep for a round 6 tilt at swannie….
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: vented enough over the weekend, go nothing left. Brag? See:round five score…..

  • Team Name: Rubitonurnuts
    Round 5 Score: 2167
    League Results: W W W
    DT Studs: Swan, Scotland, Dangerfield, Boyd, Pendlebury, Martin, Heppel, Goodes
    DT Duds: Kreuzer, Malceski, Goddard
    On the Chopping Block: none
    Round 5 trades: none
    Vent/Brag/Whatever:

  • Team Name: Ken’s Colossi
    Round 5 Score: 2,219
    League Results: W
    DT Studs: Swan (loophole), Thompson, Grimey, Hmac, GWS lads (Jmac, Cameron, Bugg, Shiel)
    DT Duds: D.Smith, Hale, Hargrave
    On the Chopping Block: D.Smith, Hale
    Round 5 trades: Maybe D.Smith to Pfeiffer or Horsley
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: My best ever weekly result…with three named players getting zeros, had emergencies correctly placed for once.

  • Team Name: YeatmanIndustries
    Round 5 Score: 2167
    League Results: WWW
    DT Studs: S. Thompson (C), Danger, Murphy, Lake, HMAC
    DT Duds: Goddard, Ellis, D. Smith
    On the Chopping Block: No one
    Round 5 trades: Mummy to HMAC, Kennedy to Treloar
    Vent/Brag/Whatever:
    Big boost in the rankings and last minute captain decision for Thompson, weekly rank 582

  • Name: Rambo Tambo
    Score: 2017
    Results: Wx5
    Studs: Swan (C), Thommo & Rocky
    Duds: Late withdrawals from Hargrave & Birchall giving me a doughnut & sub vests from Smedts, Ellis & Devon Smith.
    Chopping Block: Devon Smith
    Round 5 Trades: Depends on selections but probably bring in Heppell this week

  • Team Name: Moon Boots
    Round 5 Score: 1891
    League Results: L W W
    DT Studs: Grimes, HMac, Heppell
    DT Duds: Franklin, Goddard (C), Hargrave, Porps and Birchall for being SOFT
    On the Chopping Block: Me for making bad choices
    Round 5 trades: None, unless there’s some injury news
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Lost my league game by only 5 points, bad calls cost me. Played Giles ahead of Maric, if I’d left it would’ve won by 2. Putting the C on Goddard instead of Boyd was just stupid

  • Team Name: The Vixens
    Round 5 Score: 2020
    League Results: W W W W W
    DT Studs: Deledio, Heppell, Swan, Pendles, Chapman, Martin and the GWS lads (Bugg, Greene, Old mac)
    DT Duds: Franklin, Goddard, Hargrave, Porps, Clarke, Cox, Franklin, Smith (sandi, ablett and shaw for all being injured)
    On the Chopping Block: Porp
    Round 5 trades: Porp to a cheap Stevie J
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Frustrating times with these injuries and late withdrawals so early in the season.

  • Team Name: So long gayboys

    Round 5 Score:2218

    League Results:wwwww

    DT Studs:Swanny (capt), hayes, martin, dangermouse, boyddy, h mac, and the GWS rooks

    DT Duds: ENRIGHT!!!, Goddard, stevie J & Buddy

    On the Chopping Block: Enright is gooonnneeee!!! stevie J is pushing it too, D Martin was also about to get the chop..

    Round 5 trades:Magner-Mcdonald

    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Best round score i have got, averaging 2060 now, after a disgusting first round when i was on my honeymoon and didnt select captains or subs :/
    Ranked 140 in the comp this week, i was feeling sick though when i saw magner on 67 at half time of the dees game, just as i traded him out, but mcdonald still went better.

  • I have the following players;
    Burchill, Coniglio, Porps, Hargraves, Goddard and Jelwood.
    2 donuts to cop.
    1827 score.
    68,000
    Ranking slipped from 3000 – 9000.

    Ugg

  • Team Name:boot ur fc
    Round 5 Score:2098
    League Results:wins all round
    DT Studs:dids, scotland, bugg, lake, swan, boyd, j mac, greene, sidey and dangerfield
    DT Duds:franklin, M johnson, L adams
    On the Chopping Block:none
    Round 5 trades:none hopefully
    Vent/Brag/Whatever:

  • Team Name: Call Me Daddy
    Round 5 Score: 2262
    League Results: Win
    DT Studs: Swan Danger JMac
    DT Duds: Kruz who warmed the pine ;-p
    On the Chopping Block: Wanted to rage trade Morris but he is not worthy of a trade.
    Round 5 trades: Not so sure yet. May wait for Horsley on the bubble.
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Worst week ever last week so needed a good score this round. Jumped up 10,000 spots back in contention sitting inside the top 1,000

  • Team Name:Up the Guts!
    Round 5 Score: 2038
    League Results: WWWWW
    DT Studs: Swan, Danger, Scotland, Heppell, Hayes, H MAc, FrontBum, Martin
    DT Duds: Clark, Mitchell, Morris, D. Smith
    On the Chopping Block: None…just fattening the cows!
    Round 5 trades: Trying to conserve them now.
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Traded in Stanton last week and gave him the big ‘C’………took it off Swan : ( Cost me 200pts just there. Also pulled the trigger on Pav last week : (
    Pushed into top 7000, and team value cracked $10 million.

  • Help!

    I need to do a mid upgrade but none of Magner, Old Mac, Greene or Shiel are close to being ripe.

    Shiel being the only one sort of close.

    Facing a mega strong midfield this week with Swan, Boyd, MM and Pendles.

    My premos are Stanton, Thompson and Ablett but he’s gonna miss of course.

    Upgrade Shiel now?

  • Why can’t people differentiate between Daniel HARGRAVES and Ryan HARGRAVE??? the former retired from footy years ago… he did play for the bulldogs but get the fucken name right!

  • Team Name: Team Punishment
    Round 5 Score: 2,009
    League Results: wwwww/ pro w
    DT Studs: Torres!!! Swan
    DT Duds: Drummond , same as most

  • Team Name: FSM FC

    Round 5 Score: 1923 with a 0 in the backline.

    League Results: WWW

    DT Studs: Swan, Rockliff, Dangerfield, Pendlebury, Deledio. Good support from the rooks (Bugg, Greene, Magner, Giles)

    DT Duds: Goddard (I could have had Pendles’ VC score but got greedy and put the ‘C’ on BJ…), Cox, Franklin, Stevie J and Birchall/Hargrave for dropping out late. Clarke let me down with his tagging role but he has still been alright this year.

    On the Chopping Block: I’d love to rage trade Coxy to HMac and Goddard to Scotland but I won’t. Another week of fattening the cows.

    Round 5 trades: 21 remaining. All my cash cows are set up and just waiting til they max out.

    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Overall ranking of 3,876. Not too shabby, though I did drop down 1,333 spots this round. Still hanging in there.

  • Can someone please tell me what mccarthys and devon smiths breakeven is please

  • Team Name: Mr Dream Team
    Round 5 Score: 1760
    League Results: WWLLW
    DT Studs: Dangerfield, sidebottom, thompson,
    DT Duds: Birchall 0 , Hardgraves 0 , porps 0 , d smith (sub), Coniglio (subbed), ellis(subbed), cox (useless)
    On the Chopping Block: probably no one
    Round 5 trades: maybe coniglio to pendlebury or porps to either s johnson or p chapman
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: 3 late withdrawals, 3 subs and these guys were all on my field. went from 2000 rank to 10000 in one week.

  • done 2 trades which can be reversed based on team sheets….

    d.smith>pffeifer
    porpoise>robinson

    really need to start bulking up my forward line.

  • I have 200k in the bank and im wondering who i should upgrade out of Marty Clarke or Devon Smith?

    If i Upgrade Clarke which Premo DEF should i get? (i have Goddard, Deledio, Scotland, heppell)

    If i Upgrade Smith which premo FOR should i get? (i have Franklin, sidebottom, Robinson, martin, Roughead)

    • Maybe Waters in the backline and don’t discount Christensen in the FWDs. Pretty damn cheap and 95, 110 and 101 in last 3 weeks.

    • The question is where are you lacking the most? In your case I’d suggest a DEF however in saying that I think Clarke’s job on Stanton is a one off and I can’t see him being a regular hard tagger.

      He’s projected to earn about $18K next week and has a BE of 26 which he’ll get easily.

      You need to look at Rd 11 & 12 defenders – Waters has been a cracker so far averaging 90, A freo defender like Duffield could be interesting as well.

  • Does anyone know if selwood will get suspended cause if he is i am in big trouble cause have ablett out as well

    • yeah theres a fair chance, hopefully we’ll get a miracle

  • Anyone thinking of Josh Kennedy (syd)?, he could have a massive breakout year with the swans flying

    • Yes i am considering him, just keep him quiet………..
      *Sees golden stubby nominees* CRAP!

  • This a good trade

    Devon smith to Christensen

  • Thoughts on selwood out swanny in. have ablett on the bench then in one or two week my mids will look as folllows:

    Ablett, Swan, Pendelbury, cotchin,mitchell,magner

    thoughts

    • im waiting on the tribunal on Selwood before i decide to flick him, pretty sure he’ll get about 2 weeks, if so straight swap to Rockliff, Cant have him and ablett equaling over a million sitting on my mid bench

  • Team Name: DT Kings
    Round 5 Score: 2135
    League Results: WWWWW
    DT Studs: Danger, Thompson, Jacobs, Sidebottom,
    DT Duds: Goddard, Stanton, Hargrave, Buddy
    On the Chopping Block: D.Smith, Mabye Golby but he’ll survive another week.
    Round 5 trades: D.Smith Downgraded to a rookie on the Bubble.
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Sitting 506 overall, pretty happy with where things are going.

    • well done 7ator ;)

      yer, Hargrave made me get a 0

      • Cheers Bud. I had Morris as cover so it wasnt as bad, hopefully he is back next week. Havnt had the bitter taste of a 0 this year, yet.

  • Team Name: Kenjos Krushers
    Round 5 Score: 2059
    League Results: WWWW
    DT Studs: Danger, Thompson, Deledio, Martin, Boyd, Heppell, Sidebottom, Pendles
    DT Duds: Goddard
    On the Chopping Block: Coniglio to Horsely next week
    Round 5 trades: Fyfe to Cloke and Dickson to Treloar
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Back in the top 500 which is good. I need a dpp link in the midfield and considering downgrading Coniglio to Pfeiffer this week, but not too sure.

    Should I wait a week on Horsely or get Pfeiffer in this week and potentially shiel to horsely next week??

  • WOO! Selwood got off

  • anybody have any info on…

    why hardgrave didn’t play
    why malceski played like half a game (not even)
    and why porplyzia didnt play!?!?!

    please let me know whats going on with them

  • is this a bad trade??

    Green to Horsely
    porplizia toZaharkis

  • Team Name: Joshuas Juggernaut
    Round 5 Score: 2070
    League Results: WWWWW
    DT Studs: SWAN, Danger, Bugg, Lake, etc…
    DT Duds: Buddy, Cox, Waite, Smith
    On the Chopping Block: Dunno
    Round 5 trades: Fyfe to Robbo and maybe Hall or A. Kennedy to Horsely
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Went down 673 places to 506!!! pretty happy!!! used the loophole with swanny… totally worked!!! thanx!!! hargrave scared me for a sec but was all fine!!!

  • Team Name: AidansGiantEagles
    Round 5 Score: 1884
    League Results: WWWLW
    DT Studs: Murphy, Boyd, Pendlebury, Gaff, Grimes, Pavlich, Martin, McIntosh (Bench), Hawkins, Cameron,
    DT Duds: Goddard, Coniglio, Ellis, Clarke, Wingard (bench), Waite
    On the Chopping Block: Coniglio
    Round 5 trades: Porplyzia for Walker
    Vent/Brag/Whatever: Undefeated in 2 leagues