Connect with us

Club Previews

St Kilda Saints 2012 DT Preview

Unlucky not to have a trophy in their cabinet from the last few years, the Saints have (in the past) been a reliable team from which we could safely pick Dream Team stars for our teams. McRath has a look at the Saints and their DT worth this season.

Unlucky not to have a trophy in their cabinet from the last few years, the Saints have (in the past) been a reliable team from which we could safely pick Dream Team stars for our teams. All of this changed in 2011. With the photo scandal; the ongoing schoolgirl saga; a long term injury to their star player; and Ross Lyon’s anti-DT game plan – the stars did not align for the St Kilda football club. However with a new coach and a renewed faith in each other, expect things to improve in 2012. With so many changes, the question on the lips of many will be: is the premiership window still open?

Whilst the early calls are that they will slide in the new season, the St Kilda camp are buoyed with a new confidence; and with a drama free offseason they will look to prove their critics wrong in 2012 like Geelong did last year. New coach Scott Watters should bring a more DT friendly, faster style of play to the table – meaning many of our fallen stars from 2011 should once again rise from the ashes to become DT stars again. Read on to find out who will fire in 2012.

Possible Best 22

B:       Gilbert, Wilkes, Clarke
HB:    Goddard, Fisher, Polo
C:       Steven, Dal Santo, Montagna
HF:     Peake, Riewoldt, Gram
F:        Milne, Koschitzke, Schneider
Foll:    McEvoy, Hayes, Jones

Int:      Blake, Armitage, Ray, Dempster
Em:     Siposs, Geary, Simpkin

Fringe Players – Gwilt, Stanley, Winmar, Crocker, Cripps, Archer, Ledger, Webster
DT Relevant Rookies – Wilkes, Markworth, Saad, Milera, Ross, Newnes, Lever, Newnes, Ross, Andreoli

Recently Retired – Gardiner
Delisted – McQualter, Gamble, Heyne, Cahill, Johnson, Eddy, Baker
Traded – Walsh, Lynch

2012 Draw & Byes

The Saints have a fairly favourable draw this year. They only play 2 top 8 teams from 2011 twice (Carlton and Sydney) whilst also doubling up against Melbourne, the Bulldogs and 2011 whipping boys Gold Coast. Their start to the year is particularly interesting, playing the Power, Suns, Dogs, Freo and Demons to open the season, whilst also playing Richmond, Adelaide and the Suns (again) before the bye. This will mean that we should see some big scores in the early part of the season from the Red, White and Black. Another favourable thing is that they only have to travel interstate 6 times in 2012, playing in Melbourne from rounds 2-7 as well as their final 5 games for the year. This should allow plenty of time for the team to get settled and put together some decent form between games during those periods.

St Kilda shares the bye with the Blues, Hawks, Tigers, Power and Suns in 2012. This will mean coaches will have to tread carefully when selecting Saints players in their team. For those wanting both Goddard and Fisher in the backline, think twice then about Deledio and Suckling as they will all be out in what looms as a miserable week for Dream Teamers everywhere. Similarly, watch out when picking stars like Montagna, Hayes, Dal Santo and Riewoldt as they will be joined on the sidelines in week 13 by other AFL stars like Ablett, Murphy, Judd, Franklin and Martin.


Brendan Goddard – DEF – $474,200 – 2011 avg – 95.9 (22 games)

After a poor start to the year where he fell to around $325k at one point, God finished the year strongly to be the 3rd best defender overall (behind my boy Bryce Gibbs and teammate Heath Scotland) and will start 2012 as the 2nd most expensive backman. Fortunately for us, last year was disappointing by Goddard’s high standards; and he will be looking to improve his average closer to his 2010 average of 113 in the new season. He is consistent, durable and has a high ceiling plus has a favourable draw – what’s not to like?

Verdict: Capable of great feats and startling consistency; this guy should be your first lock in your backline and is a definite must have in 2012.
Expected average for 2012: 110

Sam Fisher – DEF – $415,500 – 2011 avg – 84 (22 games)

A classic rebounding defender; and a best & fairest/All-Australian player – Fisher has been St Kilda’s most reliable defender for the last 5 years. Equally adept at shutting down the play as he is at creating it, Fish has been extremely consistent and durable dating back to his breakout year in 2006. Whilst he is turning 30 this year, he isn’t showing any signs of slowing down. In a year where the Saints should bounce back DT wise, expect his numbers to rise again up to a 90 average.

The numbers:

  • Has only missed 6 games in7 years since 2005
  • Has average 85+ in every year since 2007
  • Still averaged 84 in a disappointing year for the Saints
  • Scored over 85 ppg a reliable 14 times in his 22 H&A appearances in 2011

Verdict: As durable as they come, with a consistent scoring rate; Fisher is a reliable pick in your defence alongside Goddard and Deledio.
Expected average for 2012: 90


Nick Dal Santo – MID – $512,400 – 2011 avg – 103.6 (22 games)

Nicky Dal had arguably his best year of both AFL football and DT in 2011. Another one of the Saint’s seemingly evergreen ageing stars, NDS showed himself to be the Saints most valuable player. Like both Goddard and Fisher, Dal Santo has durability embedded into his blood, only missing 3 games in the last 8 years! He has a huge ceiling – when he is on, he can rack them up like nobody (39 d, 7 m, 6 tk and 1.0 v GC in rnd 19 = 154 points). Whilst he is fairly consistent, Dal Santo is susceptible to a hard tag every now and then resulting in at times ugly scores (51 v Hawks in round 8). But if you can put up with the odd bad score, he is again likely to be the best midfield option at the Saints in 2012.

Verdict: Based on durability and scoring ability, you can’t go wrong with NDS. And with the Saints great draw this year, don’t expect him to drop off at all.
Expected average for 2012: 105

Leigh Montagna – MID – $485,000 – 2011 avg – 98 (20 games)

Ahhh Joey… After a sizzling 2009 and 2010 that saw him average 116 and 112 respectfully, many coaches picked him up last year as a reliable option in their midfield. Unfortunately, we weren’t to know what kind of carnage was about to happen. Still managing 20 games at an average of 98, Montagna was frustrating at times and definitely did not live up to previous expectations. However like Goddard, we are fortunate that this was mainly attributed to the St Kilda football club and not purely his form or injury. This means that with an improved, more DT friendly playing style, we should be able to see a better, more consistent output from Joey in 2012.

Verdict: Presents great value if he can return to his previous heights of 2009/10. At his price, Montagna has minimum risk and is a slightly cheaper option for your midfield.
Expected average for 2012: 105


Ben McEvoy – RUC – $447,500 – 2011 avg – 90.5 (21 games)

Heading into his 5th year in 2012, the Big Ben is ready to explode into a DT gun. Already enjoying a breakout year in 2011, he relished the additional time in the middle without now retired ruckman Michael Gardiner. While he started and finished the year a little inconsistently, this should improve in the new season as it was his first full year of AFL footy. Given he is the only recognised ruckman at the Saints with AFL experience; and without any competition from within; as well as the favourable draw in their favour – McEvoy is primed for a huuuge year.

The numbers:

  • Scored 100 + eight times in 2011
  • Had an amazing run of form between rounds 7 and 21 where he averaged 101
  • Has a high ceiling typified by his 139 in round 11 (against Collingwood)
  • Only has to play against last year’s top 8 teams multiple times twice

Verdict: All of the facts point to one thing – McEvoy will be a great pick in 2012. Priced at 90, he is great value for what he should achieve.
Expected average for 2012: 98


Nick Riewoldt – FWD – $416,700 – 2011 avg – 84.2 (21 games)

He has been one of the first picked and most reliable forward options for the last 8 years. However 2011 was very down on his high standards. Take away 2010’s anomaly that was mainly due to his hamstring injury; as well as this year’s debacle that was St Kilda’s first half of the year; and Nick has been a DT deity since the year 2004. Since his 2nd year, Voldt has recorded 7 seasons of 20 + games; averaged 88 a game or higher for the last 7 years straight (bar 2011); AND done so with a target on his head, constantly attracting the attention of the league best defenders. With a new coach and drama free preseason, he should feel refreshed and ready for a return to DT greatness that he had become known for circa 2010.

Verdict: I’m expecting Voldt to come out firing in 2012. With a great opening draw, he should have plenty of big scores from the very beginning.
Expected average for 2012: 95

Bargain or Breakout

Lenny Hayes – MID – $382,800 – 2011 avg – 86 (2 games)

If you haven’t already, go back and read my ‘Versus’ article to see my thoughts on Lenny. At his price he looks great value for what he is capable of. His preseason is coming along well and looks to be gearing up for the start of the season. If he’s fit, he will be an absolute steal. Priced at just 77, expect him to make some money and become a handy scorer along the way.

Verdict: Bargain. Lenny should make amends for 2011 and return a respectful average in the new season.
Expected avg for 2012: 102

Jack Steven – MID – $394,500 – 2011 avg – 79.8 (20 games)

One of the promising young midfielders in the St Kilda circle, Steven is ready to take the rains and issue in a new era in the red, white and black. Enjoying a great season where he played 20 games for a respectful average of 80, Steven is primed for more midfield time in 2012 as the Saints prepare for life after Hayes, Montagna, Dal Santo and co. If we take out 2009 where he only played 1 game; 2012 will be his 3rd year in the AFL. With his scoring curve on the way up, expect this to continue to rise in a new season where improvement will be expected and youth will be given more chances as the year goes on.

Verdict: Breakout. Watch for Steven to spend more time in the middle during 2012 and show improvement in his numbers across the board.
Expected avg for 2012: 90

Sam Gilbert – DEF – $345,600 – 2011 avg – 69.9 (22 games)

After two great seasons as a high scoring, rebounding defender, Gilbert was badly affected by poor positioning by former coach Lyon; as well as sustained pressure following his inexplicable behaviour in last year’s offseason. His DT average dropped by over 23 points as he was forced to pinch hit in the forward line for much of the season. With a new coach, hopefully everyone comes to realise that his best football is played running of the half back flank. Gilbert will be one of many to watch in the NAB cup to see how Watters will play him in 2012. If the above comes to fruition, we should see him DT output return to premium status and be one of the best value buys of the season.

Verdict: Bargain. If Gilbert looks to reprise his 2010 role, get on early as he returns to DT prominence.
Expected avg for 2012: 88


Beau Wilkes – DEF – $98,700

Recruited as a mature age player who is ready made to step in to the 22; Wilkes should see a lot of games in 2012 rotating between fullback and as a third tall forward. Whilst not likely to score highly, he is likely to have higher job security than many other rookies in this year’s class.

Expected games in 2012: 16 +
Expected avg: 60
Rookie rating: 7/10
Verdict: Wilkes will be a popular pick in the backline this year as he looks to fill the void in St Kilda’s team made vacant by Zac Dawson.

Jack Newnes – MID – $98,700

Taken as St Kilda’s third pick in the 2011 draft (37 overall), Newnes is a good size and could come in and fill a number of positions in the Saints team. He has a great kick, good hands and loves to tackle; if he gets a run he could be a good downgrade target. Compared by Coach Scott Watters to Lenny Hayes, Newnes is a star of the future.

Expected games in 2012: 8-10
Expected avg: 70
Rookie rating: 6/10
Verdict: Look for Newnes to earn his chance in the senior side later in the year with Watters looking to youth in 2012. He could be a great downgrade option.

Jay Lever – RUC/DEF – $98,700

The young Geelong Falcons ruck should see some time down back/fwd late in the year if an opportunity arises. Also look for him to provide some support for McEvoy by pinch hitting in the ruck towards the end on the season. Besides Rhys Stanley and an ageing Jason Blake, Lever is one of the few tall options on St Kilda’s list. Standing at 200cm, he may not score highly but could offer us with a downgrade for Stephenson or Giles mid-season.

Expected games in 2012: 4-8
Expected avg: 40
Rookie rating: 5/10
Verdict: His DPP gives him additional value as a mid-year downgrade target. Don’t expect him to give us good numbers but could offer valuable cover late in the season.

Ahmed Saad – FWD – $115,800

The pocket rocket from the Northern Bullants, Saad is an exciting prospect that only started playing AFL 5 years ago. Despite this, he managed to kick 50 goals last year from his 20 games in the VFL. Likely to get a crack at senior footy this year, Saad will add another small forward to the St Kilda arsenal. He may have to bide his time behind Milne, however like the other rookies, expect him to make an impact when he makes his inevitable debut.

Expected games in 2012: 10 +
Expected avg: 60
Rookie rating: 7/10
Verdict: If Saad gets a run early, jump on as he should be ready to play straight away.

Others to Consider

Adam Schneider [FWD, $393,000, 2011 avg – 79.5 from 20 games] – Averaging around 80 ppg and only missing 4 games in the past 3 years, expect Adam’s numbers to rise in 2012 along with the rest of the team.

Arryn Siposs [FWD, $177,100] – An accurate kick with great hands, watch for Siposs to get more opportunities in 2012 and increase his average. Priced around that of # 1 draft pick Jonathon Patton, this kid is a solid option as a cash cow.

Terry Milera [FWD, $115,800] – Another mature aged forward recruit taken to add some depth to an ageing Saints team, Milera should make his debut mid – late season and provides us with a solid downgrade target for our forward line.


Also – head to the link below for a look at stkildathunder’s previous review for a different perspective.

Click here to read stkildathunda’s preview from early January.


Thanks for reading – McRath

Who loves a number? McRath loves a number! Not only does he crunch the numbers for his own team, he is an integral member of the DT Talk team across the season providing heaps of great content! Follow him on Twitter: @McRathDT.



  1. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 1:25 pm

    Anyone taking a punt on milne?

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 1:56 pm

      Would like to punt him in the head!

      • Avatar


        February 6, 2012 at 2:04 pm


        • Avatar


          February 6, 2012 at 11:35 pm


          • Avatar


            February 7, 2012 at 2:29 pm

            depends on crameri

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 5:31 pm

      I don’t cick punts

    • Avatar


      February 7, 2012 at 7:17 am

      I’ll be punting on him for first goal every week that’s about it

  2. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 1:43 pm

    What a disgrace the St Kilda FC is. Another era done and dusted without a flag. *spitting noise*
    As for their DT Champions, too old & too slow. Pass for me (except for maybe Goddard Montanga Nicky Dal Hayes Mcevoy Reiwoldt)

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 2:20 pm

      go f yourself keyboard warrior

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 2:37 pm

      BAHAHA……..*spitting noises*

      • Avatar


        February 6, 2012 at 3:49 pm

        when you are you people going to realise that TKOL aka Simon is the King of winds ups !

        certain people need to get a sense of humour !

        bahahahahahahaha ;)

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 2:48 pm

      If you can pick 3 or 4 premo’s from the one team they’re still pretty DT relevant if you ask me. They may not win the flag (or make the finals) this year but will still give us more than they did last year DT wise

      • Avatar


        February 6, 2012 at 3:37 pm

        +1 i think the saints players are good to pick up early and cash in on them….. fisher will out score delideo in first half of year.( i think so). i have GODdard fisher nicky dal lenny and saint nick….. after reading this i mite change to mantagna instead on nicky dal

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 10:21 pm

      That post sounds like a perfect description of “The Kings of Leon”

  3. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 1:45 pm

    Watch Cripps, Ross and Ledger in the NAB cup… Jack Steven is mini Swan. Jusr the way he plays and runs… Saints have a beauty in him

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 2:15 pm

      Agree Ike – had Steven in my prelim team when he was named MID/FWD on FF – devastated when I found he was only a MID… there went his chances of being in my team. Still… will be a star in a few years.

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 3:36 pm

      Think the Saints will give early games to the def and for rookies and as pointed out, guys like Cripps, Geary, Siposs, etc. Personally hope Ledger and Ross pop up later in the year – two very hard at it midfielders.

  4. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 1:54 pm

    Great write up McRath. I agree with you about Scott Watters bringing a more DT friendly, faster style of play to the table. Wilkes looks like he may provide some value as a reserve in the backs with good job security.

  5. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 2:17 pm

    Lenny Hayes @ 102 would start in my team but I’m not sure he’ll do it coming back from a knee at 32 years old

  6. Avatar

    Relton's Roberts

    February 6, 2012 at 2:31 pm

    Up the Saints!!!! Big year coming for them. Expect to see them take the game head on and actually run! Montagna will have a blinder this year

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 3:28 pm

      I think you’re the funniest profile in the history of my life!
      Hooray Relton!

      • Avatar

        Relton's Roberts

        February 6, 2012 at 6:57 pm

        He was a champ! Burger king

        • Avatar


          February 6, 2012 at 8:40 pm

          Actually KFC..

        • Avatar

          Uncle Fester

          February 6, 2012 at 9:12 pm

          Wiping the tears away from my eyes. Go Relton.

        • Avatar


          February 6, 2012 at 10:23 pm

          Shit, gonna rename my team “The BurgerKings of Leon”

  7. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 2:39 pm

    Good write up mate, but some thoughts on your selections in best 22….

    Whilst has happened since you wrote it, Raph Clarke is out for 3-4 weeks with yet another calf injury.

    Dean Polo will not be in our best 22, Jamie Cripps will be playing off the backline, especially with Clarke having another setback.

    Simpkin will still be given first crack at Full Back. Wilkes will play as a swing man up fwd/back.

    Watters has come out and said he expects 2 or 3 players to debut in round 1…. Sebastian Ross is impressing everyone & will be first in line to take one those spots. Ahmed Saad & Wilkes the other two.

    Sam Gilbert has also been training as a full back, so watch what they do with him during the NAB Cup.

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 2:51 pm

      Cheers for the feedback – missed the news on Clarke (my bad)… Yeah I agree with you about polo – lot of kids coming through that will get plenty of chances to impress which means players like Cripps, Siposs and Simpkin will play a lot of footy. Wilkes is a shoe in – Also liking Seb Ross – haven’t read a lot on him but does look like he’ll play a bit this year.

      One of the teams to watch in the NAB to see how Watters makes them play and who he plays in certain roles (Gilbert, Wilkes etc)

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 4:19 pm

      What do you think Cripps’ chances are for playing Round 1, stkildathunda?

      He is a little pricey to have sitting on the pine when there are sooo many other juicy rookies to choose from.

      • Avatar


        February 6, 2012 at 5:09 pm

        @McRath dont worry the injury about Clarke only came out today, think after the article was published!

        Strongly believe Cripps will be in the team round 1 unless he gets injured. Also watch out for Geary, those two have been the standouts this preseason for mine.

    • Avatar


      February 7, 2012 at 2:16 pm

      do not touch ross or saad. neither will get time this season.
      under good skies in adelaide rd. 1 against port expect rhys stanley.
      wilkes parting the seas for an instant 100k

  8. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 3:05 pm


    • Avatar

      Ridley U

      February 6, 2012 at 9:37 pm

      Nope. No potential at all. 50 goals from 20 VFL games in his 5th year playing footy and now being on the Saints list could be mistaken as potential but don’t be fooled.

      Did you read the article at all?!?!?!?!?

  9. Avatar

    The colosses of clout

    February 6, 2012 at 3:31 pm

    Hey guys, tossign up between these two combos:

    Leigh Adams and Miles, and

    Dangerfield and Dom Tyson.

    Any help?

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 3:43 pm

      danger mouse and Dom (mike) Tyson……. danger-mouse WILL explode this year….. i no pple say is every year but under Sanderson he will blossom

    • Avatar

      Ridley U

      February 6, 2012 at 9:50 pm

      Try and find another option :-)

  10. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 3:38 pm

    Good write up :)

    WOW its been a long time , its good to be back

    • Avatar


      February 7, 2012 at 8:17 am

      Why would u leave?

  11. Avatar

    Alex's All Stars

    February 6, 2012 at 4:26 pm

    Gwilt not in the starting 22? – Have I missed something?

    Great write up, I’m not sure about the Saints, there are a lot of other younger faster teams up and coming. I think Ross Lyon jumped ship to one of those squads knowing that.

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 4:31 pm

      Still hasnt resumed full training after knee injury. Ive assumed his best 22 was based on who would be available round 1… But yea Gwilt is a walk up in starting 22 when fit.

      • Avatar

        Alex's All Stars

        February 6, 2012 at 4:41 pm

        Cheers for the info, didn’t know about his injury.

        Makes sense for best 22 for round 1. Gwilt’s got to be one of my favourite St Kilda players.

        Milney happens to be sitting at the opposite end of the list :-P

        • Avatar

          Relton's Roberts

          February 6, 2012 at 7:00 pm

          Milne is a champ. Never forget that

          • Avatar


            February 7, 2012 at 2:04 pm

            goes good against port rd.1 RR

  12. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 4:36 pm

    Polo and Clarke over Gwilt? Nice article, apart from this strange outlier.

    • Avatar


      February 6, 2012 at 4:37 pm

      Posted before the comment above me had appeared, sorry :)

  13. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 4:48 pm



  14. Avatar

    spartan crumpet

    February 6, 2012 at 5:40 pm

    ahh , bring back relton roberts. i was one of the idiots that had him for a few rounds hoping he wasn”t a one game player.
    not sure about st kilda players this year, waiting to find out their style for this yr under watters

    • Avatar

      Relton's Roberts

      February 6, 2012 at 7:01 pm

      Make that one game and then a 1/4 of another. Then into the rooms for a burger with the lot after he got knocked out

  15. Avatar


    February 6, 2012 at 6:25 pm

    Riewoldt a certainty in my team, my wife’s, in SC and the budgie’s! Bargain price.

  16. Avatar

    Ridley U

    February 6, 2012 at 9:45 pm

    Great article again.

    Just a quick question about Gram. Is he likely to play more forward this year? Noticed he was named as a half forward.

    • Avatar


      February 7, 2012 at 10:46 am

      I think Gram will play a similar role as last year but there will be more rotations through the midfield with Hayes likely to be eased back in and the emergence of Steven, Ross and co. Wouldn’t be surprised to see Gram pushed forward a bit more but will still play on the wing predominantly

  17. Avatar


    February 7, 2012 at 11:19 am

    Hey Mcgrath, whatsthe lowdown on siposs? If he gets a callup round 1 do you think he’s worth adding? How many games roughly do you reckon he’ll play and what do you see him averaging?

    • Avatar


      February 7, 2012 at 1:40 pm

      Siposs looks to be on track to get more opportunities in 2012. Watch the NAB to see how he’ll be used and whether he looms to be a best 21 player. I think he’ll improve and at $177 he’s not too badly priced but i think there are better options for cheaper at this stage

  18. Avatar


    February 7, 2012 at 1:55 pm

    Awesome write-up and after reading this should I go Zaharakis or Roo?

    • Avatar


      February 7, 2012 at 2:21 pm

      i’m going zaka only coz he’s DPP and has it very easy to rd.3. saints away in rd.1 and roo will take his time. zaka will be at full tilt from the start.

    • Avatar


      February 7, 2012 at 2:38 pm

      I disagree – not 100% sold on Zaha… Think Voldt will avg 95 and give us some massive scores with the Saints favourable draw in the firs half of the year… Zaha had a recurring injury last year which meant he spent most the the week recovering after games… He still managed to play well enough to be B&F but I’d look into that before committing to him. I’d rather Robinson, Martin or Sidey OR Voldt all before him. But I am a Blues supporter…

      • Avatar


        February 7, 2012 at 4:46 pm

        i’m a saints man and it doesnt please me but i’m taking zaka and not volt. why? round 1 trust me, volt wont go high 90s. ur a blues man mcrath and sorry but i reckon zaka will tear your boys a newy in rd.3. at least with zaka i can do something with him, volt just sits there. cheers.

  19. Avatar


    February 7, 2012 at 4:22 pm

    I heard they signed up Peter Files to arrange their after match functions :)

    • Avatar


      February 7, 2012 at 4:48 pm


Leave a Reply

More in Club Previews