My Team: Version 4.0

The final week of the JLT is here and so is a new My Team. Version 3 is running through the JLT Series… so get your chatter happening as the games play out.

Post your team (in an easy to read format) and discuss where it’s at in the comments below. Now that we have My Team cranking, discuss any players, team structure, etc in the comments. As always, keep it civil and if you’re advice, make sure you dish out some of your own (make sure it well thought out and not blatant trolling – we’re totally over that after 10+ years of DT Talk!).

Get keen for a massive season ahead.

Join our open DT Talk league – EJEFTZ9H

Click here to subscribe on iTunes. (Please leave a rating and review to help us move up the charts).


  • Sicily and Rockliff
    Savage and Parker


  • Rank in order…

    Jackson Trengove, Tom Bell, Matt Taberner, Mason Cox, Jarmen Impey, Mark Hutchings, Allen Christensen, Cam Ranyner

    • Christiansen then Rayner. Just dont do it to yourself with the others

    • Supposedly Hutchings has been training and doing drills as an attacking midfielder and hasn’t discussed anything about tagging as will go to a youngster.
      R1 will be a test against Sydney. If it is true, an absolute bargain forward and number 1 on list.

      • It kinda looked like this in the JLT. If true he is very tempting

      • There was a story on Hitchings in the West Australian a few days ago. Skimmed over it but off the top of my head he’s lost 6kg as they try prep him to step into a midfielder role this year instead of his former fwd or tagging role.

    • I get the reasoning for looking at them and Taberner, Bell and Hutchings have been on my radar as well Trengrove did well in JLT as well. The level of risk though is high but one way to look at it is the risk is less risk in terms of job security as they are more likely to play.

      You can also tier them the same such as instead of Christensen at 331K have Hutchings at 370K and Rayner at 270K have Fox 284K but in midfield not forward.

      They are options and the risk is not necessarily any greater. If you roll with a couple and get it right thats the reward for those who take the risk. BTW…i am

      • Currently have Christenson, Tabs and Hutchings. Don’t like forward rookies and can’t see them losing money.
        Rayner I can’t see scoring enough consistently with his inflated price and JS.

  • Duncan + Sicily

    Steven + Hibbo

  • Beams and Natanui or O’Meara and Goldy

    • Tough but option one the two haven’t played any JLT and at some stage the risk has to get to high.

      I know Nat played some district and Beams is just having extra time for his body and mind. You would want to see them though, and of course Goldy had a great half and O’Meara is getting better

  • Does anyone know when we will get updated images for players eg Holman not having one and the eagles players still having their old guernseys.

  • Hearing Yeo may play a bit more forward this year, turned me off him a little bit. thoughts on that statement by Simpson?

    • With there loss of midfield talent, can’t see him playing the fantasy backrole at all
      Kennedy and the other big men injured he could be used forward to pinch hit but mainly see him mid as they need a bigger body there or will get smashed by Sydney.
      Therefore see a big drop in points and $$$ for anyone starting him

      • Agree I wouldn’t start him, don’t think he will be on the back flank early on where he thrives, which is disappointing as a wc supporter I think we will need him back there. Yeo yeo scores will be back if he goes forward imo, hope I’m wrong.

  • Rocky, Parker, Neale, Coniglio and Beams… need two for M4/M5

  • A few more spots left in tonights A Quick Draft’s A Good Draft:


    at 9pm ADL time (9:30 Eastern)

    6 teams, Captains Off, 60 second picks (no ghosts please!!)

    2/3/1/2 4 emergs. Snake. Starts R1

  • Nic Nat not playing for east Perth today… potentially resting his body for a round 1 return, could be picking him up for fantasy round 3-4 if everything goes well….

    • I think he will play R1 and you need to either pick him then or not at all
      Doesn’t score enough to be a keeper so by R3 will be too late to make you enough cash to be worthwhile

      • I wouldn’t touch him in any form this season, the general will catch up with him if you select him, he will miss games.

  • is it too much having christensen and bell in the fwd line? Bell F4 Christensen F5. Cant trust the rookies in the fwd line personally

  • M.Crouch or Parker who will average more?

  • Out of the midfielders 270k and under? Apart from brayshaw who will average the most – doesnt matter about price. Thinking Dow, cant trust kelly, perhaps LDU for his JS. Basically, who will average the most apart from brayshaw in the mid rooks.

    • Kelly is definitely the best but JS is a worry after R1 Danger returns then 2wweks later Selwood returns. Struggling to see where he fits with GAJ coming in from last year on top of that.
      Next best is Barry but don’t like his security either
      Holman and LDU have best security but not best scorers
      Dow could be best overall just based on security and then score

      • Don’t discount Banfield – looked very impressive and a seasoned body who won Sandover Medal in WAFL last year.

    • Well the best imo would be Constable. Unfortunately he won’t get enough games to be a viable selection.

  • Cant decide between my two teams, to make it easier, here are the players unique to each team

    1) Dusty (M3), J.Kelly (M4), Holman (M8), Smith (F3) and Ryan (WCE) (F5)


    2) Beams (M3), Neale (M4, Parker (M5), Christensen (F4) and Waterman (F6)

  • Thoughts on which option guys?

    Lloyd & Robinson
    Sicily & Greene/dahlhaus

    Trying to figure who is a more risky picks out of Sicily or Robinson, Sicily with the tag or Robinson with injuries

    • Can’t trust either but Lloyd better than Greene/Dahl

    • Is tight between the options but i don’t personal rate Sicily as high as people seem to this year and Greene looked good in his half of footy 48%TOG for 70. Robinson and Sicily both went at 76 PP100 so which one?

      I would go neither and have Lloyd and Greene

    • I would go lloyd and petracca

    • Thanks for the feedback guy’s, I made some cash by going neal to cogs, which allows me to go with Lloyd & McLean. Wich means i avoid having both Sicily and Robinson in the team

  • Thoughts on my team? Tweaked it since last time it was touched, also not sure whether to play 2 or 3 rooks in the midfield.

    DEF: Laird, Hibberd, Sicily, COffield, O’Shea, Murray (Keefe, Doedee)

    MID: Titch, Zerrett, Treloar, Parker, Coniglio, Armitage, Brayshaw, Dow (Banfield, Holman)

    RUC: Jacobs, Gawn (English, Cameron)

    FWD: Heeney, McClean, Smith, Christensen, Fritsch, Waterman (Giles – Langdon, Vanebels)

    Also left with 10K left to spear. If O’Shea is not named for first round will probably swap him out with Naughton and either downgrade Dow to Kelly or Jacobs to Ryder

  • Afl Fantasy DRAFT ON TONIGHT! 2942A6JL

    6:30 AEST. 7pm adelaide time. Captains on. 8 players. Please dont join unless you are going to be actively engaged in the draft. Cheers

  • Is Billings, Heeney, Petracca, Christensen too weak for F1-4?

    • No I dont think so, a lot of people have smith at f3, and I think petracca could avg similar. As long as you are utilising that extra 60-70k

    • I’m thinking of doing the same get rid of Sic Dawg.

  • Is it bad only having 2 mid rooks?

  • Need to pick one of the below….who would you take?

    Neale or Beams or Kelly (GWS) or Zorko

  • Buddy and Rayner or Hutching and Robbo?

    • Hutchings very underpriced and will most likely go 75+, robbo very similar maybe a bit better.

      Option 2 will probably be better points wise, however I would feel safer with option 1. If you are a risky person go option 2.

  • DEF: Lloyd, Savage, Ryan, Naughton, Coffield, Murray (Doedee, Finlayson)

    MID: Mitchell, Martin, Neale, Parker, Fyfe, O’Meara, Fox, Brayshaw (Banfield, Holman)

    RUC: Martin, Gawn ( Cameron, Frampton)

    FWD: Franklin, Billings, Caddy, Hutchings, Rayner, Fritsch (Giles-Langdon, Waterman)

    Thoughts on this team?

    • Problem with this team is you have wayy too many round 14 bye ‘keeper’ players in your side in my opinion…

      You might have to cull a few or you will be hurt come bye time.

  • What do people seeing Sic Dawg ave? Would he be a headache?

  • RMT. In need of advice (aren’t we all?)

    DEF: Laird, Lloyd, Brayshaw, Coffield, Naughton, Murray (Doedee, Finlayson).

    MID: Titch, Zerrett, Treloar, Parker, Whitfield, Coniglio, Brayshaw, Banfield (Holman, Barry).

    RUC: S.Martin, Gawn (Cameron, English).

    FWD: Buddy, D.Smith, T.Bell, Christensen, L.Ryan, Fritsch (Waterman, Keeffe).

  • First year of fantasy so any thoughts are helpful
    Defs: Laird, Yeo, Lloyd, Coffield, S Murray, Doedee
    Mids: Mitchell (c), Whitfield, Coniglio, Treloar, Zorko, T Kelly, P Dow, A Brayshaw (Banfield)
    Rucks: Gawn, Martin
    Fwds: Petracca, Heeney, Billings, Rayner, Fritsch, Hutchinson

    Undecided on bench with 50k left so maybe move coniglio up to a Kelly or take Martin up to Kreuzer
    Thanks for tips

  • Stef + Sicily or Nank + Hibberd (Melb)??

  • Nank and Rocky


    Sandy and J.Kelly

    • Option one but I wouldn’t go Sandi or Rocky.
      Maybe Nank & neale/parker/whitfield/coniglio/fyfe type. But if your gut feel is rocky then back him in!

  • Hey boys, how does my fantasy team look at the moment, thinking of dropping Dow and getting a 170k rookie for ~70k extra. 2k left

    Def: R.Laird, J.Lloyd, J.Crsip, N.Coffield, A.Pearce, S.Murray (T.Doedee, J.Finlayson)

    Mid: T.Mitchell, A.Treloar, D.Beams, L.Parker, L.Whitfield, A.Brayshaw, P.Dow, T.Kelly (N.Holman, B.Banfield)

    Ruck: M.Gawn, J.Witts (D.Cameron, W.Frampton)

    Fwd: I.Heeney, D.Smith, M.Walters, J.Sicily, A.Christensen, B.Fritsch (J.Waterman, L.Keefe)

    • Not too bad, walters is a risk and could give you a 30 every few weeks but also can pump out a 130 on a good day, other than that looks good.

      See whos selected to play Rd 1 if you want to downgrading dow

  • Adding another competitive league to the list.

    The Motley Crew
    Invite code: 39XTJ36T

    Lets see if we can fill it up!

  • DEF: R. Laird, J. Sicily, A. Brayshaw, N. Coffield, S. Murray, T. Doedee (L. Keeffe, J. Finlayson)

    MID: D. Martin (VC), M. Duncan (C), M. Crouch, S. Coniglio, B. Fiorini, J. O’Meara, A. Brayshaw, P. Dow (N. Holman, B. Banfield)

    RUCK: S. Jacobs, M. Gawn (D. Cameron, W. Frampton)

    FWD: L. Franklin, J. Billings, T. Lynch(ADL), D. Smith, D. Fogarty, L. Ryan (D. Venables, W. Rioli)

    52k left in the bank, my second year, any suggestions appreciated

    • I like it, got some PODs in lynch and fiorini but backline is a little weak

    • Not sure about sic dawg very up and down imo so risky at D3 maybe a brawshaw would be a better option

      Fiorini could be a gem, especially now hall out, I’m liking that POD pick but not one for me, lyons could also be a gem, o meara I question, not much ball, but will rise in price

      Jacobs is interesting maxed out imo, perhaps think goldy… looked great in preseason and then use that money + the 52 to upgrade sic dawg

      Not sure about foghorn, job security not there when tex returns… id reconsider but if jenkins is shit like he has and he performs maybe… but then they wouldn’t have a back up ruck for jacobs, so yeh minimal job security imo, but liking T lynch! Unique and one I’ve gone with too!

    • I would even the lines out some. Defence will be difficult to trade up as the season starts when you need to up as many as 4 of them

  • Danger, Dusty, Rocky and JOM vs Neale, Parker, Whitfield and Jelwood

  • Please join Sportsdeck league 382573

  • Out of a few of JLT performers Hall, Whitfield, Parker or Cripps. All 690-693K

    • Hall injured.
      Parker (for points), Whitfield (DPP) then Cripps for me

      • I was thinking that, with Hall close as he seems to have the Ablett role and i am thinking Whitfield may have more in him now as the role is right and can out score Coniglio

  • Need some advice..
    D Smith or Sicily

  • In mins
    3 spots left in tonights A Quick Draft’s A Good Draft:


    at 9pm ADL time (9:30 Eastern)

    6 teams, Captains Off, 60 second picks (no ghosts please!!)

    2/3/1/2 4 emergs. Snake. Starts R1

  • Gday fellas heres my team what do ya think?

    DEF:Laird Lloyd Brayshaw Naughton
    O’Shea Doedee (Finlayson Murray)

    MID:Danger Dusty Kelly Coniglio Beams Coffield Dow Brayshaw (Holman Banfield)

    RUC: Grundy Hawn (English Frampton)

    FWD:Billings Buddy Acres Christenson
    Fogarty Fritsch (Waterman Rioli)

    I’ve got 83k left
    Thinking of going Brayshaw from dees to Armitage? Also Stef or Kruzer instead of Grundy?

  • Billings, Heeney, Robbo, Bell Hutchings, Christensen Fwd Line

    Yay or Nay?

  • I have noticed a fair few people jumping on Fogarty (Crowfog). I’m pretty sure Murphy is ahead of him. Are there any crowd fans who are able to shed any light on these 2??

  • New Elite Draft league. Live draft Monday 19th at midday AEDT. Join if you’re keen on sticking with it all season. Code = AYW3MWHK

  • is it too much having christensen and bell in the fwd line? Bell F4 Christensen F5. Cant trust the rookies in the fwd line personally.

  • Got a few spots in our Elite Draft league. Live draft Monday 19th at midday AEDT. Join if you’re keen on sticking with it all season. Code = AYW3MWHK

Leave a Reply

To get your own unique avatar for DT Talk comments, please go to and sign up with the same email address you have signed up here with.