Connect with us

The Thursday Scramble

The Thursday Scramble: Round 2

One week down but we now have some Byes to deal with! Time to Scramble!

Now that was more like it. 9 games, can’t wait for that again this week…. hang on, you are telling me there isn’t? Yup, we are a couple of teams down this week wit a couple of byes, but really this is the ‘easier’ week of the early bye rounds it seems. So, let’s make the most of it and Scramble!!

Bye Rounds

So we were all so worried about them but now they are here it doesn’t seem too bad. This week is the easier of the early bye rounds with Carlton and Brisbane on the bye. We don’t have as many Fantasy Relevant players from those teams that will cause too much issue. Zac Williams is really the main guy that we have from these teams that will have an impact. Remember that it is Best 18 this week so even if you don’t have much in the way of cover for him you shouldn’t be disadvantaged.

As you trade this week just keep the upcoming weeks in mind. Particularly if you are bringing in a premium. In round 3 we have the Suns and Giants on the bye. So this is probably one of the early bye rounds that is going to impact a lot of coaches, so just bear that in mind.

Price Changes!

You would have noticed that in AFL Fantasy, any player that played in Round 0  and in Round 1 would have had a double dose of price change this week. In that format of the game we are now back on track with price changes and from here on it is just normal price changes cycles.

In both Supercoach and RealDreamteam, where players have to play 3 games before they have a price change, we are going to see players from Gold Coast, GWS, Collingwood, Melbourne, Sydney and Richmond all have price changes after this week as Round 2 will be their third games. So beware of this! Obviously players from Carlton and Brisbane will fall back into line with all the other sides given they have the bye this week and have their price change next week.

So just be prepared in Supercoach and RDT that you will see some prices change after round 2 which is something we aren’t used to.

Best 18

Here we are with the first of the early bye rounds and as we all know all of these rounds are now Best 18 rounds, if you are new to this, all this means is that your best 18 On Field players count. All of the Emergency rules still count, so if you have a full field of players playing then your emergency will replace anyone that is a late out on field.

This can obviously mean that it should be easier to do your loopholing as most rounds (maybe not this one) you are more than likely to have a player on their bye on your field.

Just be very wary of these rounds and make sure that you have as many players playing in field as you absolutely can.

Fallout from Round 1

Last week we saw some big scores where we didn’t expect them and some poor scores where we expected some big ones. Now don’t panic as this isn’t special, we see this all the time. There is always someone that jumps out of the gate and they don’t have another big score for the rest of the season. Similarly, last season we saw Laird have a stinker in round 1 and heaps of coaches jumped off, but we then saw him recover from there for a great average. So knee jerk reactions aren’t always the best way to go in this game.

Remember this is a trading game and to make good trades we need to make some good cash to be able to do it, so for me the key trades to make this week are trades that are going to make you money.

In regards to a few players here are some thoughts.

  • Brody Grundy – I would give him another go. He gave away 7 free kicks and he isn’t going to do that every week (hopefully). If you are determined to trade him, then Xerri is the answer to free up some cash.
  • Crows & Suns players – I would write off most of this game as it was a horror night weather wise. I heard today a stat on one of the podcasts (sorry I can’t remember which one other wise I would give some credit) that there were 114 marks in the game compared to the 118 that the Suns alone took in round 0.
  • Caleb Serong – Yes he had 46 touches in round 1 but is he going to do that again each week? No, so if you are planning to bring him in that is a perfectly good move, but just don’t expect the massive score each week.
  • Isaac Heeney – It is going to be very hard for Horse Longmire to move him out of the midfield given the way he has been playing so he is so is a great option to bring in.
  • Riley Bonner – I am still a little unsure on him. Sinclair is back this week but Crouch has been dropped so it will be very interesting to see how he goes with this change in dynamic. Again, not suggesting he is a bad selection but just be wary.

Things to Remember

  • You don’t win or lose Fantasy in round 1, as Selby says, this is a Trading game not a starting squad game.
  • Keep an eye on future bye rounds when you are making your trades.
  • You aren’t going to get the right rookies every week, so don’t stress on that, just use the best judgement you can.
  • Keep an ear out for the Submarine, he had a pretty good hit rate in round 1 so let’s see how he goes with round 2.

Have a great weekend and let’s look to consolidate our teams. Don’t blow them up, every player can have an off week. As with past seasons I will try and jump on and answer some of your comments, but this doesn’t always fit in with work so sorry if I don’t. Anyway, See you next Thursday!

A passionate Port Adelaide Fan who simply loves footy! That is how I would describe myself. Catch my weekly article "The Thursday Scramble" with all the last minute things to think about for the weekend Follow: @pkd73.

30 Comments
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
30 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
doug
doug
9 months ago

many thanks Dunny!!
bye round planning has me brining in Serong (top 5 player but no cash left) or Rozee (top 10 player with some extra $$) & Sharp (couldn’t get him in the original squad)..
agree with Grundy, need to see another game before deciding to get Xerri in or not..

doug
doug
9 months ago
Reply to  Dunny

Serong+Coffield vs Daicos+Sharp??

big time last minute scramble, but think i prefer Sharp over Coffield with Daicos being a wash with Serong..

downside is i get a 2 bye player (Daicos), but he is DPP and about the most consistent player in the comp..

Anthony Ellul
Anthony Ellul
9 months ago

Dunny, is it better at this early stage of the year to try and get rookies I missed eg. Sharp or Dempsey or chase a must have who will finish top 6 in the def line sheezel??

Dulcify
Dulcify
9 months ago
Reply to  Anthony Ellul

My thoughts are that it is better to grab the rookies you missed because each week you don’t pick them their prices continue to rise and it doesn’t take long for those players to then become too expensive. Good luck.

Barney
Barney
9 months ago
Reply to  Dulcify

Depends on your squad. No defensive rooks to get in for Reid, so maybe a Massimo is the right move as a mid pricer that can get cash and points. But if you have a dud mid/fwd/util rook then def gotta take Sharp or Dempsey…
Reckon I’m going double mid pricer,
Wines – Bonner
Reid – Massimo
Hopefully two decent rooks to attack following week

Western wonders,
Western wonders,
9 months ago

Is it ok to go into the next round with 388k, if you did a wines to bonner and a dud-arick to Massimo for value. Or should Clark instead?

JungleMuffin
Member
9 months ago

I’d say it’s too much generally, but with it being a best 18 round it won’t hurt as much as usual.

George
George
9 months ago

Hey mate great write up as always!
What are your thoughts on Grundy to Xerri and Wines to Billings via DPP
Have All the important rooks besides Dempsey but like the upside in the trades mentioned above
Thoughts from Dunny or anyone would be appreciated :)

Squid
Squid
9 months ago
Reply to  George

Personally I’d be (am) holding both of those guys, Grundy dominated Gawn the game before and looked great doing it, wines just cruised around in second gear but when he did pop up also looked really good, weagles were pretty bad and Wines is a bloke who rises for a contest, pretty sure both will be fine long term.

Like Dunny said I’d be concentrating on max rookie cash generation but if you truely have everything in order besides these two things you certainly could have a crack at the trades mentioned, my only concern would be Xerri does look good but is still unproven and an injury risk and Billings can be a bit up and down though he looked really good slotting in with the Dees and has proven scoring ability.

George
George
9 months ago
Reply to  Squid

Thanks squid, I have the good rooks besides Dempsey who I’m a little unsure on anyway and the potential upside & cash gen from Billings and Xerri is very tempting, billing’s against hawks could easily drop another 100+ score
And for wines I know it was eagles but I just don’t trust his role especially when you have 3 star mids in Rozee Butters JHF
Oh decisions decisions…

The Chosen Won™®©
Member
9 months ago
Reply to  George

Good Luck

Last edited 9 months ago by The Chosen Won™®©
George
George
9 months ago

Good luck to you too haha…

Brother ewwww
Brother ewwww
9 months ago

Hey Dunny, who would you trade wines to… Bonner or M.Crouch? Cheers

JungleMuffin
Member
9 months ago

Love it that so many people are jumping off good picks that I also own.

Mememe
Mememe
9 months ago

Hey Legends,

Couple of options here

do i bring in crouch and have minimal cash in the bank

OR

drop down to bonner/billings/dambrosio and pocket $300k for the next few weeks.

if the second option, who is the best pick?? dambrosio will push coffield to the bench, bonner will push sharp to the bench and billings will push lazzaro to the bench.

Petez
Member
Petez
9 months ago
Reply to  Mememe

Crouch is a potential set n forget for a long time to come. The other 3. It’s hard to tell. But I guess it’s what the extra cash allows you to do next week.

It’s irrelevant who on the field this round
Those bottom shit scores will drop out
Next 2 weeks only Top 18 scores count

JungleMuffin
Member
9 months ago
Reply to  Mememe

A or B both acceptable, question for option B is who you’re downgrading/upgrading.

Who you’re cutting would determine if I went option B or not.

Mememe
Mememe
9 months ago
Reply to  JungleMuffin

thanks mate, im dropping wines

Petez
Member
Petez
9 months ago

I’m having 2nd thoughts lol. Bonner or Dambro… Anyone got a edge. I’m leaning to Bonner

JungleMuffin
Member
9 months ago
Reply to  Petez

I’m currently Moving Fisher out for Bonner, although my Def is complete already, with Coff/Howe on the bench, so I’ve not considered Dambro at all.

Bonner will probably average higher I think?

Petez
Member
Petez
9 months ago
Reply to  JungleMuffin

My defense is good. No rookies. It was Wines to Bonner or Dambro. With Yeo to dpp into mids. Then Newcombe to Serong. The other option I got is to hold wines. Drop sexton a week early to a basement rook under 260k and upgrade Newcombe to Serong. But cutting sexton early is not ideal..

But I have all the cash gen rookies besides Dempsey. So I’m good there for cash gen

Petez
Member
Petez
9 months ago
Reply to  Petez

If I had of picked Dempsey over Watson..I flipped a coin lol. I could move Yeo out instead of wines. But cash only allows to move wines

Western wonders,
Western wonders,
9 months ago

BONNER ROCKET!!!

Western wonders,
Western wonders,
9 months ago

And I need steele




Recent Comments

  • Hunter on My Team 2025: Launch: “as a stepping stoneDec 21, 16:10
  • Hunter on My Team 2025: Launch: “Nick daicos as m1 and c?Dec 21, 16:09
  • Matt on My Team 2025: Launch: “I reckon Clarko will use him as a playing coach, so JS nor solid. Limited minutes.Dec 21, 13:31
  • Sjeje on My Team 2025: Launch: “With this years draft crop am I crazy for having 0 230k players on the bench excluding Gibcus and Zach…Dec 20, 22:14
  • Phteven on My Team 2025: Launch: “Possibly 12 to 16 that will keep your score ticking over, potentially. Benchers look satisfactory at this stage.Dec 20, 20:29

Podcasts

Advertisement

More in The Thursday Scramble