Connect with us

The Game

2019 Hindsight Heroes

Hindsight is a wonderful thing. Rohan looks at how you could have won AFL Fantasy Classic by 5,500 points.

Back in round 17, I presented a team that was almost 4000 points in front of the competition using the power of hindsight. Well, after the final 7 rounds of the season, that number is now up to 5500. You would’ve won the competition at the completion of round 21. Not only that, but it also won the highest round score a whopping 14 out of 23 times!

The team used a grand total of 58 players through the season, finished with an overall team value of $20.6mil and has $1 million still remaining the in bank. The teams average score per round is half a point short of 2500, including going over 2700 4 times and amassing a huge score of 2839 in the Grand Final!

Only 6 players made it through the year without being traded; Duursma, Danger, Boak, Grundy, Gawn, O’Brien. Plenty others were traded out and back in, so to not be traded is a pretty good achievement.

Before I get on with the team, here are some takeaways:

  1. Hold your rookies as long as possible. This team still has 5 rookies it start with, allowing for maximum cash generation from them. All rookies were held until they reached peak price, then traded, but of course this is only possible with hindsight.
  2. Sideways trading is the way to go. Almost as soon as a player went into a form slump, they were traded out of this team, most often to a player currently in a great patch of form.
  3. Don’t worry about the byes so much. I didn’t even consider the bye structure for this team until a week before, it turned out to be pretty balanced in the end anyway. With 3 trades a week, it was easy to field 18+ each week.
  4. Don’t be afraid to field rookies over premiums. It happened rarely, but quite often I’d find a rookie scoring a lot more than a premium, in which case it was proper to bench the premium. If you can predict a bad matchup for a premium and a good one for a rookie, don’t be afraid to bench said premium.


Here’s a quick reminder of who was lucky enough to start in the side:


Or, See rounds 1-16s team breakdown here



Score: 2761 (rank 1)
Highest actual weekly: 2659
Captain: Dunkley 189
Total score: 41326 (rank 1)
Points in front: 3957
Team value: $19.95mil ($855k rem salary)
Trades: Coniglio > Hunter, Ziebell > Greene.


Score: 2752 (rank 1)
Highest actual weekly: 2700
Captain: Grundy 181
Total score: 44078 (rank 1)
Points in front: 4134
Team value: $20.72mil ($457k rem salary)
Trades: Lycett > E.Curnow, Chol > Whitfield.


Score: 2488 (rank 2)
Highest actual weekly: 2518
Captain: Dusty Martin 133
Total score: 46566 (rank 1)
Points in front: 4312
Team value: $20.93mil ($390k rem salary)
Trades: Marshall > Worpel, Stack > Bontempelli.


Score: 2764 (rank 1)
Highest actual weekly: 2695
Captain: Macrae 151
Total score: 49330 (rank 1)
Points in front: 4567
Team value: $21.10mil ($272k rem salary)
Trades: J.Clark > Houli, Parker > M.Crouch.


Score: 2695 (rank 1)
Highest actual weekly: 2579
Captain: Lyons 158
Total score: 52025 (rank 1)
Points in front: 4977
Team value: $20.96mil ($427k rem salary)
Trades: Billings > Ablett, Walsh > Pendlebury.


Score: 2624 (rank 1)
Highest actual weekly: 2572
Captain: Dunkley 150
Total score: 54649 (rank 1)
Points in front: 5132
Team value: $20.94mil ($627k rem salary)
Trades: B.Crouch > Neale, Lloyd > B.Smith.


Score: 2839 (rank 1)
Highest actual weekly: 2762
Captain: Neale 162
Total score: 57488 (rank 1)
Points in front: 5551
Team value: $20.64mil ($1,056k rem salary)
Trades: Greene > Cameron, Worpel > Suckling.


Ah, hindsight is a wonderful thing.

– Baked Beams ✌️


Recent Comments

  • Nathan on My Team 2024 – Round 16: “he was also playing on the wing for half the gameJun 24, 13:24
  • Koden on My Team 2024 – Round 16: “Is it better to keep Schoenmaker on my field for one week to get rid of Clayton or should i…Jun 24, 13:01
  • jag67 on My Team 2024 – Round 16: “Definitely did consider him last week, but he still held a reasonably high BE plus inconsistent form over the previous…Jun 24, 12:38
  • Squid on My Team 2024 – Round 16: “I went nowhere too, I’m also ranked about last overall… Funnily though the only real difference between our teams this…Jun 24, 11:14
  • jezza on My Team 2024 – Round 16: “DunkleyJun 24, 09:48



More in The Game