Calvin’s Captains – Rd. 21

My Top 3

Let’s keep this nice and simple and I’ll explain to you why these lads grabbed the top 3 spots this week. Scott Pendlebury has only played at Etihad Stadium twice this year for scores of 133 and 124 and loves playing under the roof. He had 141 and 107 on the Roos last year and with previous guns like Jobe (132) and Boyd (115) scoring solidly on the Roos in recent weeks, you’d assume he’d get it done this week. His team mate Dayne Beams is in the same boat. He had 116 on the Roos last year and had 137 in his last run at Etihad. But it’s his form that just keeps rolling which gets him high in my top 5 this week. Beams carries a lowest score of only 113 in his last 5 games this year with an average of 121 in his last 3. Freaking impressive.

But it’s Gary Ablett who will be locked in as my #1 again for this week. Ok, so he only had 99 last week after a terrible start of just 26pts at the half. He came home strong and let’s face it, everyone had him locked in anyway. He is averaging 127 in his last 3 games this year and this week he plays the Hawks at the MCG, a ground where he has only played twice on this year for scores of 130 and 186 – Boom. Ablett killed the Hawks last year with scores of 135 and 147 and should be around that mark again this week. Over the last 5 weeks, arguably the best DT gun from opposition teams have top scored for their team against the Hawks. Boak (108), Selwood (125) and Watson (108) all were ok but it was in the Collingwood game where the guns really shone against them. Swan (165), Beams (147) and Pendles (142) found plenty of the rock and even before that Boyd (131) was great as well. Back in the gun and look out for a huge score from Gazza this week.

When do you need a smokie?

Great question I have asked to myself, and the answer is quite simple. If you don’t think you can win you’re league match this week by going head to head with your opponent, try to grab a sneaky 100pt bonus with a smokie captain.  Assume they will go will Ablett and therefore you are after a miracle! An injury, or a low score to the great man will leave you with a huge advantage… yeah it’s a long shot, but at the end of the day you were probably going to lose your league match anyway. So… what options do we have?

Firstly, look at my other picks other than Ablett, like Beams or Pendles. But if you are after a big smokey? Try one of these guys.

Dean Cox had a huge 147 last week and did have 118 on the Power last year. He averages 100 at AAMI in his last 3 and let’s not forget that even Giles (124pts) tore Port apart two weeks back. Whilst on the topics of Rucks, Cox (147) and NicNat (111) dominated Geelong last week as Orren had his work cut out for him big time. This week he is in doubt meaning that Geelong will go into the game without a recognised ruckman, so watch out for Ben McEvoy to have a big one as well.  Trent Cotchin is another after his massive 152 last week. He goes for his 7th straight 100+ score this week and did have 112 (30d) on the Dockers this year in Rd. 11. In that game, Crowley went to Deledio and will again I’m tipping after it worked and Freo won. Delids had just 78pts (15d) and should be avoided based on this. Plus, his highest score against them is only 114 (2010) over his career of 10 games against them. Sam Mitchell is up against the Suns and he had 132 on them in one of his games last year. He hasn’t had anything over 109 in his last 4 this year, but he will this week at the MCG. I won’t support this one, but Adam Goodes did have 150 and 129 on the Bulldogs last year and has a highest sore of 90 in his last 5 games this year, but he pushes the term ‘smokie’ to ‘ridiculous smokie’ in my eyes. My biggest and best roughie for this week is clearly Scott Thompson. He’s not in my top 5 as that is based on reliability etc… But we are talking smokies. Now, he hasn’t scored over 100 in his last4  games this year, but oh my he will this week. Last year against the Lions he scored 138 (38d) and 126 (36d) and avoided the tag of Raines who went to Dangerfield where he only managed 50pts. If Raines leaves Thomo alone, he might just go bang this week.

Who will be your round 21 captain?

  • Gary Ablett (58%, 1,048 Votes)
  • Dayne Beams (18%, 325 Votes)
  • Scott Pendlebury (5%, 91 Votes)
  • Trent Cotchin (3%, 50 Votes)
  • Sam Mitchell (2%, 40 Votes)
  • Scott Thompson (3%, 52 Votes)
  • Dean Cox (4%, 65 Votes)
  • Jobe Watson (4%, 66 Votes)
  • Someone else (4%, 66 Votes)

Total Voters: 1,803

Loading ... Loading ...


  • think an honorable mention to Trent Cotchin for his first appearance on the top 5 captains list.

  • not sure.. went gazza last week and i wasnt pleased to see him at 33 points in 3rd quarter…

    boyd or gazza for me…

    more and likely will go gazza…

  • Nice Top 5 Calivn, I have all of the top 3.

    However, since I’ve got the week off and going straight through to the prelims, I’m going for a smokie. Tossing up between McEvoy who should tear up with no Cats ruckman but also tempted by Thommo since he’s an absolute gun.

    • I wouldn’t count on it, against Melbourne McEvoy scored a whopping 69 against… Jake Spencer? Jake WHO? Went a long way to costing me the one league match I wasn’t top 4 in (Lost by 40).

  • hmmmm….. I’m STRONGLY considering beams over gazza this week…. but I just know gaz will go big if I don’t put him captain…. only in two semis this week so I’ll consider going unique…. but you can’t really go wrong with gaz…. right????

  • sidebottom as a smokey??????

  • gazza!

  • Going Zac Dawson as a smokie. He should bounce back well after his score of 7

  • Not going gazza, every time he’s number 1 he has a shit week

  • who will go to GAJ? or will the hawks let him run around like they’ve let other guns do in the past?

  • Got the week off so Beamsy for me.

  • I’ve got the week off in all of my leagues, so will probably end up experimenting with the captaincy this week. May as well.

    Beams or Pendles being the most likely to don the ‘C’ I reckon.

  • Calvin, what’s with the lack of love for Jobe? 3rd highest total average and no1 overall points scorer. I think he’s only made your top 5 twice this season. Is he your Captain or something?

  • No love for Marc Murphy as a smokey this week? With Judd back the opposition’s attention will once again be divided, as it was at the start of the year.

    • Aaaaand this is why you should trust your own judgement. I don’t know what possessed me to pick Watson as Captain. Luckily I have the week off.

  • has got to be gazza… interesting to see goodes as a roughie! thoughts if he should be on the field instead of zorko/ robinson?

  • Needed a smokey last week knew my opponent would go gaz so I went pendles turned out to be the difference in my upset win. But this week I’m confident head to head so gaz for me!!!

  • Trent West is back this week, so Geelong will have a ruckman.

  • What are people’s thoughts on Dangerfield as a roughie?

    • Im strongly considering Dangerfield! Although not sure about being in Brisbane,…….
      Doing my head in… Have reverted back to Gaz,,,,,