Connect with us


It’s time to go… Josh Hunt

This is Big Brother, the public have voted and it’s time to go Josh Hunt. Or is it? A lot of people have brought up the possibility of trading Hunt this week. Should you?

There was a whole heap of value in picking Josh Hunt at the start of the season. He was a perfect price for a 7th defender… or even on your pine. And now, he has probably maxed out in price with his breakeven of 66 this week. He’s made almost $60K and prime to downgrade, or help upgrade.

Downgrading this week is a perfect option. If he is on your bench, then go for it without thinking twice. If he is your 7th defender, make sure you are happy with what you would get from the guy that will end up being in that 7th position. Most likely a Matt Maguire, Ben Nason… or the new dude who is traded in.

So, who should the downgrade be to? There are three blokes prime for the picking this week. Ashton Hams ($77,800), Phil Davis ($94,500) and Simon White ($77,800) have all played three games and your guess is as good as mine for the best bet there. But here’s my ranking for them:

  1. Ashton Hams: Rd 4 – 48, Rd 5 – 68.
  2. Phil Davis: Rd 4 – 69, Rd 5 – 71.
  3. Simon White: Rd 4 – 58, Rd 5 – 74.

I would only pick Hams over Davis for his name – how cool would that look in your backline? But seriously, their job security is about the same – maybe Davis is slightly better. The big thing for me is the extra cash you can save by going the rookie listed player.

The tough thing with picking a guy for your bench for downgrades, you are unlikely to be trading them again to make cash. You possibly could, but in my opinion, you’ve gotta look at this guy you trade in to play out the season.

If Hunt is on your ground, then you should be looking to sure up that position with a bit of a gun as soon as you can. It would be fine to ride out a Maguire or Nason in that position – as long as you can take a shitful score or two for them over a couple of weeks – and then look at getting on Ryan Hargrave in a week or two for a straight swap from one of them. Hey, Brendon Goddard will be within range soon.

This goes into planning your trades, which I will cover in another blog post soon. But has to be something to think about!

If you’ve got some coin in your bank, how about a straight upgrade to someone? Who could it be? The positive about this trade is that you will have $144,700 in the bank to play with. Plenty of potential for upgrades there!

Co-captain of DT Talk since inception in 2007. Finally had a good season with an overall ranking of 137th for 2018... next goal is to replace the dirty old trucker hat with an AFL Fantasy one! Follow on Twitter: @WarnieDT



  1. Avatar


    April 29, 2010 at 12:36 am

    Davis is the best option if you have other DP players – Waite, Grundy, ect

  2. Avatar


    April 29, 2010 at 2:41 am

    christmas has come early – hams in hunt out.

    so cheap and shown enough. Pretty much trading hunt for his former self a few years ago…these blokes are both nuggets.

    Get on the shaved hams

  3. Avatar


    April 29, 2010 at 10:32 am

    Scotland or Duffield?
    Dal Santo or Montagna?

    Should I trade Nic Nat for Cox or Warnock for Cox and leave Nic Nat on the bench to cover Cox?


    • Avatar

      timmy t

      April 30, 2010 at 1:57 am


      And I’d trade Nic Nat to Cox. Although Warnock is out this week, he has a much lower BE than Naitanui so definitely has more potential to earn you more cash. He’ll be back in a week or so.

  4. Avatar

    timmy t

    April 30, 2010 at 1:09 am

    I went Hunt to Davis but now I’m not sure what to do…

    I can either upgrade Watson to Montagna or make another downgrade and wait a week and go Watson to GAJ. Monty is due to go down in price a bit this week too but I’d like to win this weeks game as I am 0-2.

    What do you guys think I should do?

    • Avatar


      April 30, 2010 at 3:17 pm

      Abblett is injured so prob not.

  5. Pingback: maiunemn scaprtsi

  6. Pingback: water in basements in Lake Darby OH

Leave a Reply

More in DT TALK