Trade Talk Tuesday

If it’s not enough that our players are getting injured and dropped, hows the frustration levels at premium priced players scoring less than rookies on a consistent basis (Greg Broughton). I mean I am totally against trading out premiums or “keepers” so to speak but when Broughton is continually getting outscored by the likes of Danny Stanley…… something has to give. At this stage in the year, I still believe you need a good reason to trade eg. I think it’s a bad idea to trade premium to premium just to avoid the bye. In my eyes that is small gain with no sustainable long term gain.

With the help of the assistant coach, here are a few players worthy of discussion under differing categories.

Cash Cows:

Tom Liberatore: 
Average:88  Break even:-77  Price:$158,900

Josh Toy:
Average: 64  Break even:-53  Price: $97,600

Brodie Smith:
Average: 71  Break even: -47  Price: $152,800


Brian Lake:
Average: 58  Break even: 201  Price: $414,300

Brendon Goddard:
Average: 86  Break even: 172  Price: $438,100

Marc Murphy:
Average: 102 Break even: 155  Price: $405,100

Jump on:

Nathan Fyfe:
Average (last 3): 106  Break even: 1  Price: $333,100

Jed Adcock:
Average (last 3): 96  Break even: -10  Price: $293,100

Get your ideas out there guys, discuss all things trade here. Have fun!!


  • should i trade varco for fyfe?

    varco 61,93,56,54 ave 66 300k
    fyfe 95, 65,117, 137 ave 106 330k

    • What do you think mate?

      • im thnkin this could be a purple patch and he will go back to scoring 60s like last season (probly slightly better). its a risk cause there are player like cyril and ben mcglynn avaliable (mcglynn super consistent doesnt score less than 80

    • hmmm, tough one that.

  • Robbie Tarrant out for Brodie Smith?

    • B Smith was brilliant in a poor side last week

      although if the crows get back some players he’ll get a rest at some stage
      i’d reckon… he’s a gem…

  • FFS- for fyfe’s sake!!!
    95 vs Lions
    65 vs Cats
    117 vs Crows
    137 vs Kangas
    So hes done well vs poorer performed sides, & not so well vs a genuine side!
    Don’t get carried away is all I’m saying.

    • very true…..he is a very good player, but how good…..only time and quality opposition will tell

  • Is it worth getting J.Voldt in now? He is only 260 and they are playing the roo’s this week.
    How about Boomer Harvey?

    Needing to trade one forward out because I wont have an emergency otherwise ( and that is including using my DPP as well)

    • Btw probs going to get rid of McGlynn from Swans because He is producing a constant 80’s, but I want atleast 90’s and can get anyone but Chappy.

  • Want to trade out harry o’brien for a better scoring player like deledio? have 21 trades remaining and 134000 left in the bank? thinking it will be a good move have too many pies players and would be a good opporunity while deledio price is low. any thoughts?

  • Gram, Enright or Delidio which is best option????

  • Broughton

    Away in round 6 bye

  • Broughton >>> Adcock????

    Bruce (maybe) >>> Brodie Smith, Only if Bruce has a relatively high chance of being the sub?

    • Bruce to brodie smith No way Bruce just scored 100

    • I’d wait 1 more week with Broughts as he has the bye in rnd six, then you can trade away if underperforms again.
      Do not trade out Cam Bruce!!!
      I had Smith from the beggining, but wasn’t looking good last week until he junked it up in the last qtr!
      Nice little player tho!
      Remember the aim of this game is to try field a team of 22 premiums- dont go backwards, still 20 rounds to go!

      • my only concern with bruce is even though he just scored 100, he had a pretty poor game afl wise. making him easy pickings for punishment as the sub.

        Broughton i believe his time is up, if i trade him it has to be now, im not gonna wait till he drops in price yet another week and adcock is on fire!


      • Broughtons BE is 127 so he’s likely to haemorrhage heaps of money if he scores shizer again, which he’s likely to do given his (perceived) change in role this season. Personally I’m offloading him for Toy or Smith or Otten this week, can’t afford to lose another 30-40K on him.

  • Okay this is doing my head in but thoughts welcome on the following options (have 22 trades left):

    Option 1:
    Brought to Brodie Smith
    Petrie to ZSmith
    Do that this week as Z smith will go up about 30k next week.

    Then next week Krak or Matera to Dids (know he has a bye in rnd 7 but only interested in league wins)
    That will leave me about 70k in the bank


    Option 2:

    Broughton to Gram
    Petrie to Zac Smith

    Leaves about 60k in bank.


    Cheers in advance.

  • Definately going broughton ton b.smith and will probably go kraks to curnow. Thoughts? And Please dont tell me i am an idiot for now already having curnow because i know that.

  • A bit off topic guys, so forgive me, but…

    Chris Dawes verdict is in:



    Woo-hoo! this is sweet sweet news for my forward line!! :)

    • Just sh!ts me that appeals like that always go collingwoods way

      … interested to know under what criteria he got off, as all the guidelines are fairly fixed

    • well done Dawsey!!!!!

  • Pav pleading guilty, but challenging that it was negligent not reckless.

  • chris dawes getting off is bad it just means more chance for krakouer to get dropped!

    • you would think it wouldn’t matter. Can you see Krakouer as a key marking forward?

  • I have a reasonable but not great team. Top 15k nationally.
    Bit concerned about Vickery and Petrie.
    I can downgrade Vickery to Zac (+ 20ppg) and upgrade Petrie to Higgo (+40ppg).
    This will leave me with 20 trades and 90k in the bank.

    Plan to bring in Chappy later 20k short now.

  • Whats everyone’s thoughts on broughton?? should i trade him out 4 B.smith or give him 1 more week??

    • Another week, he could be worth 280k with scores of 50-60. Im trading him for Toy or Smith this week before he bleeds out! I was leaning toward Adcock or Gram but extra $$ may be a problem.

      Ill use the extra $$ from the Broughton downgrade for my Chapman,Selwood or Montagna upgrade in coming weeks

  • yeah i was gonna do that but i could use the extra money$$$ for upgrading.

  • going vickery>sandi

    then should i trade okeefe?
    i can afford any mid/fwd

    my midfield
    swan, boyd, montagna, selwood, okeefe, curnow (harris, bewick, irons)

    franklin, johnson, n.riewoldt, pavlich, knights, krak, darling (matera, pitt, richardosn)

    okeefe, krak, pav =dpp

    trade okeefe to anyone?????


    • If u must trade him go to rockliff but it’s not like he’s been getting 60’s each week like a certain pair of freo defenders. I’d say keep him but up to u if u think it is worth a trade.

  • Does anyone think

    1.Broughton > Toy
    2.Krak > Didak

    are good trades? Ill have 156k left

  • What do we think about Brodie Smith? will he be able to keep his scores and is he worth trading in, cos i already missed curnow dont wanna miss another.???

  • Does anyone think that with Suban out Broughton’s scoring will increase. If not Gram or Adcock in?

    • Here are the probs Im facing in the same situation (Im assuming u have Broughton and u want to stop the bleeding of cash)

      Broughton – New role, not DT friendly, dont think he’ll take Subans role
      Adcock – Drummond is in and alot of people are saying Adcocks scores will suffer
      Gram – St Kilda are crap at the moment, Lyon may change roles on alot of Saints, including Gram

      So Im going for a rookie to make me some cash immediately and in the long run, then upgrade someone else to a real premium with the $$ made

      • Gram can only go back or midfield really.

        And he is awesome and runs up the ground off half back anyway.

        • Broughton was one of the best according to the papers against the Roos (not in DT land) so im guessing Ibbotson will take Subans role, gonna trade Broughts – Toy. GC have bug all defenders at the moment so Toy is gonna get a few games hey…$$$$$ :) and then Kraks to Libba before he explodes

  • Hi all

    B – Grimes, Gibbs, Goddard, Suckling, Adcock, Heppell, Duigan (Toy, Stanley, Lower)
    M – Swan, Selwood, Boyd, Curnow, Libba, D.Swallow (Harris, Buckley, Krakouer)
    R – Cox, Sandilands (Vickery, McCauley)
    F – Franklin, Goodes, Johnson, N.Riewoldt, Knights, Tapscott, Darling (Prestia, Richardson, Matera)

    Whats my next move here & when? Thinking of getting Mitchell & Pendlebury in soon or even Thompson???

    I’ve got $375,800 in the bank.

    Any suggestions?


    • Too many mid price and rookie defense on field for my liking.

      When Suckling peaks or maybe after this week because of hawks bye trade to Enright, Gram or Deledio.

      Upgrade peaked mid soon to Mitchell which will probably be Libba because you wont want to trade Curnow anytime soon.

      Get Pendlebury later after round 13 bye

  • broughton to adcock then krakouer to zaha or duncan. what do you guys reckon

    • Duncan is a test with a bout of general soreness

      Zaha will be up and down like essendon

      Try and get to Fyfe or Dawes if possible.

      My advice hold Krakeour

  • The injury curse has hit big time.

    Bad start to the year, i had Connors, so last week traded in Suban. Fantastic!!!!!

    Coad does his hammy. Leaving me with a bench of Lower, Pedersen and Puoplo.

    Big decision this week. Pray that Krakouer plays and doesn’t lose his spot to ‘The Hard Man” Dick.

    Hate to think i will have no way out of a donut since i have Goodes, Darling and Tapscott out with the stupid multi bye.

    Saving grace is that i have $141 100 in the bank.

    Im thinking of trading in Rob Murphy. But there are other options but will leave me no cash for a trade to get atleast a decent trade for Coad. Fingers crossed North and the Hawks do their part in what could be a very, very, very ordinary Round 5.

    Whats the consensus on Broadie Smith Vs Andy Otten. Have not seen any of the Crows games this year.(Dont get me started on the Foxtel rip-off) But will see them get a 8 goal loss to the MIghty Blues!!!!!! Gibbs for the big C this week.


    • B smith was great…

      Otten burned every touch he got…

      given the crows have lots of injuries it’s hard to see either of them losing their spot
      might see otten as the sub though…his disposal was shite lwknd…

      • Thanks mate. I think ill be barrarking for Broadie just a bit on saturday night. But i can see Krak getting dropped.

  • Krak > Fyfe
    And if lower isnt playing, Lower > Adcock

    Seems good to me, any thoughts? Only thing is I will only have $2000 after the trades.

  • can anyone stop me from making a brain fade trade to bring in higgins?

    is he gonna play more this year? or piss around with niggles?

    anyone got him? happy? or….just plain sacred he’s gonna
    blow up any second…

    • I got him. And im happy at the moment but have figured out at start of year that could use a trade to get him out. Can all the Doggies put it together this year????<<<<Pass mark – Grand Final

    • got him and very happy

      • i just noticed the doggies have freo away, pies and swans in the next three…

        thanks for the views…

        if they cant do it this year, when will they?

        porbably hinges on higgins and co staying on the park…
        time will tell
        good luck

    • I asked the same question.
      Carried his ar$se all last year for 70s, noob mistake.
      Looks like he is fit.
      Atm I may sit on Petrie, he is set to rise, if modestly and has a couple at the darklands next few.

      If ur in the Petre dish and have money in the bank, you will be able to upgrage to Chappy rd 7. I go to most cats games and he is working into it nicely. Should drop to around 410-420k around then.

  • Gents, what does dpp stand for – double position player? How does this work, does it mean you can move them from say a midfield in to a foward role instead of acutally trading?

    • yes genius you can move them around… it doesnt cost you a trade. for example you can move A. Krakouer (MID/FWD) and D. Prestia (FWD/MID) around between the fwd line and midfield without using a trade.

    • it means you can swap players between these possies …you must have one dpp in each area to do it though…good luck

  • need to trade in adcock as a cheap upgrade to my backline. who should i trade out?

    backline is: gibbs, deledio, grimes, heppel, toy, otten, duigan, smith, lower, hibberd

    what should i do?

    • i’d be keeping an eye on how otten plays this week…

      his kicking since the knee has been horrible?
      constant skill errors aren’t conducive to getting games

  • hey lads,
    what do we think about montagna this year.payed a lot of money for a man bein consitently outscored by much cheaper options. i love the guy as dt star but is letting me down big time this year. was thinking of trading him to higgins (DPP handy) and freeing up some cash to upgrade the horrorshow that has been andy krak.

  • Interested in people’s thoughts:

    Trade Josh Hunt for Fyfe
    Trade Jarrad Grant for Adcock.

    Only complication to this otherwise straightforward trade is that I have Lower and Krak. Both are passengers at the moment., but not likely to loose much value, whereas Hunt and Grant are almost certainly going to loose value after next round.

    • You mean hunt-adcock and grant-fyfe right.

      Lower should be back this week and honestly Krakeour will improve and I don’t think will get dropped.

      So go for it Grant sucks and if you like Adcock do it

  • Thoughts on Patty Ryder? regretting picking him over cox. Worth keeping or trading? My first ruck is Sandilands of course

  • DEF: Gibbs Deleidio Heppell Lower Adcock Duigan Goddard (Otten Stanley Puopolo)

    MID: Judd Swan Pendlebury Boyd Curnow swallow (Maloney Libba Harris)

    RUC: Sandi Smith (Jamar Derickx)

    FWD: Franklin Stevie J Nick Reiwordt Higgins Knights Petrie (McKernan Richardson Matera)

    well there it is advice would be much appreciated in a bit of hole not sure what do have long term plans but thinking of getting rid of petrie and krakouer

  • if you could get any mifielder (besides swan, boyd, and bartel), who would it be?