Connect with us

My Team

My Team 2023: Round 2

Discuss your two trades – and whatever else you want – right here!

Discuss your team, strategy, players, etc. in this post. Offer up constructive comments if you want questions answered yourself! Be a giver, not just a taker! This is a great community and we want it to stay that way. We love banter as much as the next person, just keep it clean!

For plenty of great stats, check out:

Fantasy points for and against

CLUBPTS
FOR
>100
FOR
>120
FOR
PTS
AG
>100
AG
>120
AG
ADE 139710149231
BRL112900164900
CAR146410153731
COL162440128500
ESS172051156831
FRE180062149410
GCS145631177740
GEE128500162440
GWS149231139710
HAW156831172051
MEL176552143351
NM155830154010
PTA164900112900
RIC153731146410
STK149410180062
SYD177740145631
WB143351176552
WCE154010155830

Don’t miss the live show every Sunday night exclusive to Patreon members.

Co-captain of DT Talk since we started this thing in 2007. Best finish was 13th in 2009... that was a long time ago. Follow on Twitter: @WarnieDT

131 Comments
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
131 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
JungleMuffin
Member
1 year ago

Round:2063. Rank:9773. Not bad, good even. But it’s the deifference between driving away in a Cruiser, and catching the bus. Would have been 2175 and ~400th or so if not for a late Witts to Xerri downgrade. Probably too far back for the car now, but still alive for T100.

Could be worse. I feel for you blokes out there who had injuries to 2-3 big names.

Final team ended up being
D: Dawson, Young, Daicos, Day, Constable, Ginbey (Cowan, Wilmot)
M: Steele, Green, Piglet, Sheed, Worpel, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Hollands, Chesser)
R: Marshall, Xerri (McAndrew)
F: Dunkley, Cogs, Tarrantino, Flanders, Bruhn, Cheezel (Green, Long)
U: Kytel
Bank: 100k

Def roughies played well, Mids played decent, Forward roughies played average. Entirely cucked by late ruck choice.

Trades this week will basically just be fixing ruck. Would like to keep Bytel, but might need to cash him in to get up to a quality ruck. Might just eat the damage for this week, keep Bytel/Hollands/Cowan, and move Xerri to a budget ruck. Should have my pick of all the battlers 😂

Votes: +3,2,1 for Young, Daics and Day in whichever order. all got their job done nicely. -3,2,1 Piglet, Flanders, Bruhn. All were looking great, then just dropped off and didn’t get the job done in the end. Mitchell has role issues, and I’ll be jumping off when its convenient.

Xerri gets the get out of gaol free card. Was spanking it prior to the injury, and looking like a Gigabrain selection. Hurts to make the right call, then get stiffed.

JungleMuffin
Member
1 year ago
Reply to  JungleMuffin

Late update to rank 9227. So thats 350 BX (Before Xerri), 9227 AX (After Roy)

brian Smith
brian Smith
1 year ago
Reply to  JungleMuffin

Bruhn/Flanders down to Chandler, Xerri to Witts?

Brad
Brad
1 year ago
Reply to  JungleMuffin

Too far back to win it?? Not even close. Keep in mind that there are ‘players’ simply going for top scores R1, R2 and possibly R3.
Ending R1 inside or close to top 10k, that’s a C score or a trade away from pushing inside top tier. I ended the round 8340. I’m happy with that and looking at trades to bang into next round.

Matt
Matt
1 year ago

Couple of good trades and luck and you can still crack top 1000 next week. You have to think alot of luck takes place in round 1, consistency through the first 3 rounds will see you back in the picture for a cruiser, alot of those teams ahead of you will be worse than yours, but just git lucky this week.

JungleMuffin
Member
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt

Yeah, for sure. In fact, I’m banking on some of the value picks that didn’t score big this week, to bounce back nicely next week. Still plenty of time, and thinks are just shaking out in the wash at the moment. First couple of rounds are just the lucky bounce that can help make the difference.

How bout chu’ Matt? How was your week?

Matt
Matt
1 year ago

I ended up just outside the top 2000 with a score of 2098, but that’s been updated twice already since the last game finished, so who knows what it will be. Think it’s really close points wise at the top as you could imagine.
I nailed alot of my picks, but I messed up and had cowan on field for 35 and then captained Laird. My other mids consist of Merrett, Green and Coniglio at the moment, so if I captained anyone of those but Laird, I’m probably looking top 50 or higher. All week I debated going down from Laird to brayshaw and Steele instead of Merrett, leaving me the opportunity to upgrade coniglio aswell, but I just couldn’t find any mid over 870, even up until mcrae that I liked more than coniglio as a mid/fwd option. I had English/Marshall Ruck combo too.
I’m not sure what to do this week, I may chase a fresh rookie as I think long may get dropped for West Coast.
Only other thing is maybe McGrath for daicos or young, maybe Laird down to brayshaw or another premo as he’s probably not going to make breakeven for 3-4 weeks. They all seem like bad moves to me though, so may just be a double rookie get week, though I had chandler, Pedlar and all the other best ones already. If I had chandler on field over Pedlar I’m probably winning the comp right now lol, but I don’t think anyone would have chosen chandler over Pedlar before this week.

Matt
Matt
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt

My bad, this was a reply to The JungleMuffin

JungleMuffin
Member
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt

I think it’s too early and royactionary to be cashing in your PODS/Value picks based on one round. Got to back yourself in a bit longer than 1 week.

Definitely think chasing rookies you missed, and replacing the ones who get dropped this week or make minimal bank with a high BE/low future profit prospects is the way to go.

Haven’t seen Chandler’s scores, but if he’s pumped out a bigun as you’ve suggested, I definitely will consider jumping on him and riding the quick rise.

Matt
Matt
1 year ago
Reply to  JungleMuffin

Yeah I feel chandler is set to play atleast the next 2 weeks 100% now that Kozzie is missing 2 games. Just when Kozzie and Bailey Fritsch are both in the side it will be hard to keep him in unless Kozzie stays a 50% midfielder, but I feel alot that don’t have him, will be jumping on him.
I’ll probably just wait for teams to come out and hope for no injuries. Laird is probably a bit more of a pod now than he was a week ago with all the reshuffling people have done, so I should stick with it.

Mr Fantasy
Mr Fantasy
1 year ago

D: Doc, Daicos, Ridley, Day, Ginbey, Cowan (Chesser, Wilmot)
M: Steele, Macrae, Dunkley, Green, Worpel. Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Hollands (Davey, Phillipou)
R: Marshall, Cameron (Heath)
F: Taranto, Rozee, Gulden, JHF, Long, Sheezel (Chandler, Pedlar)
U: Greene

Score: 2038, Rank 13537

My biggest fix needs to be Long, 1% owned midpricer pod who hasn’t worked at all, can’t have him bleeding cash and scoring sub-rookie scores like that. Constable/Bytel are the likely candidates, though I have an eye on Comben if he continues rucking (which doesn’t seem likely with Goldy in the wings)

Cameron to English is my other likely trade. Watched the Cox split with my own eyes and it caps him majorly. Watched English too and he was just so solid with 93% CBAs so I think the play is get him in asap and hold as a keeper.

As much as I’d love to have Setterfield (And to a lesser extent, Callaghan), I don’t think I’ve got the cash to get there and with his first price rise he’ll need 95ish from here to be a worthy pick. Think he’ll do well but I’ll need to be contrarian here to get to English.

Can’t think of any rookies I’m dying to get in (Ginbey, Mackenzie and Ashcroft are the big 3 due to CBA roles, Sheezel’s role obviously strong as well. Chandler won’t score like this every week), so happy to cruise on that unless team sheets absolutely wreck me.

Other thoughts:

-Picked Ridley as I saw the comp rush to get McGrath in and thought he could give a similar input at $50k less. A little concerned about ceiling though as he doesn’t tackle a lot.

-I think Dunkley’s score was an anomaly in a pretty weird fantasy game overall (no one scored over 95, which hasn’t happened in a game for 17 years according to JP.) so I’m not concerned. But please, feel free to trade him out =)

-A bigger mystery is Marshall considering he had 100% CBAs which we’ve been waiting years for. Is Darcy just a great nullifier?

-I feel like both Cowan and Hollands played better than their scores suggest.

JungleMuffin
Member
1 year ago
Reply to  Mr Fantasy

Marshall definitely had a quiet week this week with facing the dual Freo rucks. Darcy is a monster at CBA also, so took most of the hitouts that Marshall otherwise would have had for himself.

Mendoggy
Mendoggy
1 year ago

Def: Doc, Cum, Mcgrath, Day, Const, Ginbey (Berg,Wilmont)
Mid: Laird, bray, Green, Worp, Callaghan, Ash, Mackenzie, Hollands (Davey, Chesser)
Ruck: English, Marshall (Ryan)
Fwd: Dunks, Taranto, Rozee, Guld, Sheez, Poo (Pedlar, Greene)
Utl: Cowan
Kinda average week, unsure of trades this week. Any help appriaciated!
Bank 23k

Troy
Troy
1 year ago

Score-2112 Rank- 3266

Def:
Sicdawg, Stewart, Mcgrath,
Day, Constable, Ginbey
(Uwland, Wilmot)

Mid:
Jelly, Coniglio, LDU, Green, Worpel, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie
(Long, Davey)

Ruck:
Witts, Marshall
(Heath)

Forward:
Dunkley, Taranto, Rozee,
Gulden, Sheezel, Phillipou
(Pedlar, Greene)

Utl:
(Chesser)

Have to trade out Stewart after that annoying start to the season. Any thoughts?

JungleMuffin
Member
1 year ago
Reply to  Troy

How much cash have you got to play with for Stewart?

Might have to trade out one your other rooks who made minimal bank to get up to a keeper, otherwise, might be worth dropping down a touch, bringing in someone on the fringe of being a T6 Def keeper, and bringing in a rookie you missed out on.

The Chosen Won™®©
Member

2001

Captain Laird was lazy!

Good Luck me in 2024!

JungleMuffin
Member
1 year ago

The real question is……are you gonna beat da Minj?

The Chosen Won™®©
Member
Reply to  JungleMuffin

2017 CL Champion™®©
I smashed da Minj 2019 2020 2021 2022™®©
Good Luck in 2023™®©

Daniel
Daniel
1 year ago

Laird captain
Steward injured on 14
Delete team button located

brian Smith
brian Smith
1 year ago

Depends – do you hold Jelly and play Pedlar/Davey on ground for one week?

brian Smith
brian Smith
1 year ago
Reply to  brian Smith

@Troy

Stevo
Stevo
1 year ago

1996
Would you trade Laird now or give him another week?

The Chosen Won™®©
Member
Reply to  Stevo

Look at Crisp from last season 51 then 126, Just need to let Laird’s wife know how chit her husband played on social media!

2017 CL Champion™®©
I smashed da Minj 2019 2020 2021 2022™®©
Good Luck in 2023™®©

brian Smith
brian Smith
1 year ago

Doch/Daic/McGrath/Const/Ginbey/Cowan(Wilmot/Chess)
Laird/Jelly/Cogs/Worpel/Callaghan/Mackenzie/Ashcroft/Hollands(Long/Davey
Dunks/Taranto/Rozee/Gulden/JHF/Sheez(Pedlar/Greene)
English/Marshal(red dot)

On field issues: Laird (hold), Dunkley (hold), Marshall (hold), Jelly (concussion 1 week?), Cowan / Hollands – ok to hold but move to bench if poss.
Bench issues: Long / F.Green – both can go, but who to bring in – Uwland/Comben?
So do I trade Jelly, or put Pedlar/Chandler on field?
Or McGrath to Sicdog?

Cowboy God
Cowboy God
1 year ago

2144 (overall 1224); was 2157 with an overall rank of 923 until late adjustments.

Very happy with each line, managed to get the right rooks on field too.

Doch/Daws/McGrath/Const/Ginbey/Uwland (wilmot/cowan)
Dunks/Andy Braysh (C)/Green/Serong/Callaghan/Worpel/MacKenz/Ashcroft (Hollands/Poo)
Marsh/Darcy (McAndy)
Taranto/Cogs/Rozee/Errol/Sheez/Peds (Fergies/Davey/Chess)

No injury concerns, just need to make sure dunks gets his head in the game on friday.

HELP ME PLEASE!!!
HELP ME PLEASE!!!
1 year ago

Perfect team with a bailey smith captain and xerri – Fuck, thinking bailey smith to tim english and xerri to phillips or another low pricer to save cash for next week, happy with entire team except xerri.

horse
horse
1 year ago

2089 at rank 5645, overall happy with what my final team looks
+3 is tom green, witts and rookie choices apart from missing chandler
-3 jelly captain but he was tracking for a 110 if it wasn’t for the KO, fielding cowan over uwland and last minute choice of dawson over sicily although daws should avg more over the year.

Trades so far are
greene (hawks) to chandler
jelly to de goey

Balls in the air
Balls in the air
1 year ago
Reply to  horse

1981: with xerri, Dunkley and captain Laird. So thinking if I can do Sheed /xerri to Witts or english/ Phillips or Chandler is the play. Feel JS is the killer, any thoughts on rookie JS and scoring consistency from Rd 1?

Bill
Bill
1 year ago

Don’t despair if you picked Xerri, like me.
It makes life difficult, but the margins are not that great at the moment between the 5,000th and 20,000th, and anything can happen now with the concussion protocols.

The best scoring players someone had this week might fail concussion tests next week, score very little, and then will also be banned from playing the following week.

It’s a lottery to avoid the damage. Anyone can win this.

BuddyHawks
BuddyHawks
1 year ago

Score 1996
Def- Doch, daws, sis, daicos, const, wilmot (chess/Cowan)
Mid- laird, Oliver, Mac, gulden, ash, Mack, ginbey, hollands (phillipou, Phillips, baker)
Ruc- English, marsh (madden)
Fwd- Dunk, Taranto, rozee, sheez, pedlar, Greene (mcandrew/Davey)

Bank $15,400

Thoughts?

Jax
Jax
1 year ago

2158. 719th overall. I got lucky and dodged all the carnage (including not starting with Laird!). Dunkley and Marshall were disappointing but at least everyone has them. Cowan and Hollands on field hurt my score a little but both played really well.

Jason
Jason
1 year ago

Hello, anyone else unable to make changes to their team. Is lockout lifted?

Shaun Mccabe
Shaun Mccabe
1 year ago
Reply to  Jason

Something wrong with app… Unable to make changes also ????

Charlie
Charlie
1 year ago
Reply to  Shaun Mccabe

Lock out hasn’t been lifted yet.

stan the statistician
stan the statistician
1 year ago
Reply to  Charlie

and the question is why.
they seem to bungle everything

The Chosen Won™®©
Member

Lock out will be lifted once they figure out why Laird’s 114 is not doubling as Captain!

Good Luck in 2024.

MJ
MJ
1 year ago

The website is incredibly slow too. It used to show the traders tweets as well, plus the team changes/subs but not anymore. I’m assuming this site is on the way out in favour of the paid Patreon.

Matt
Matt
1 year ago
Reply to  MJ

You got that right. Trying to force us off DT talk for Patreon. It’s been 3-4 days now that dt talk has been taking a few minutes to load, they have clearly turned something off or stopped paying the bills haha

jjbkeeper
jjbkeeper
1 year ago

R1 Score – 1865
Total Points – 1865

Team (after loopholes)
Doc – Dawson – McGrath – Jones – Constable – Gibney (Cowan – Wilmont)
Laird – Steele (C) – McCrae – Sheed – Worpel – Ashcroft – Mackenzie – Hollands (Chesser – Laurie)
Marshall – Cameron (Heath)
Dunk – Taranto – Rozee – Cunnington – Sheezel – Phillipou (Greene – Long)
(J. McVee)

+ Decided to go with Steele as captain to be a bit different. Originally had the C on Laird.
– Gambling on Cunnington when I was toying with JHF over Gulden.

$84K

Trades
Cunnington > JHF
No idea on second.

ONKFISH
ONKFISH
1 year ago
Reply to  jjbkeeper

You suck just quit afl fantasy

brian Smith
brian Smith
1 year ago
Reply to  jjbkeeper

Fix rookies – Long, Laurie, Greene might not earn much cash. Maybe try to get Pedlar/Uwland/Davey who have lower b/e and will make more cash for you – if they are selected.

Matt
Matt
1 year ago

The content here is good, but it’s not good enough for people to pay and make a patreon account for it. I get what the boys are doing trying to monetise all of this, but they are way more likely to lose the community all together if they are going to turn a blind eye to all the issues on this website. People aren’t going to pay for a game that is free. They may get 20, heck, maybe even 50 people sign up for it, but that would just be a bad idea for those choosing to do that. May aswell just start a sub reddit for dt talk where we can all talk and pass comments, because this site, or patreon, is clearly heading in the wrong direction

The Chosen Won™®©
Member
Reply to  Matt

400*…

2017 CL Champion™®©
I smashed da Minj 2019 2020 2021 2022™®©
Good Luck in 2024™®©

Matt
Matt
1 year ago

Well that’s just absurd. Obviously everyone is entitled to an opinion, but the content shouldn’t be at an expense, the level of content has never been worthy of someone having to pay for it. Especially if it means they are turning a blind eye to the current site and community in an attempt to get people to pay for it. Just my opinion, but the community here is what has always had more of the discussions that help us with our teams than the actual content. Anyone that is paying for that content is just not too bright and a bit of a sheep. 90% of what we need from dt talk comes before the season starts. Once it’s started, it’s very much common sense, you can easily run your team by yourself from then. If 400 people is true, that is mind blowingly dumb. What exactly is the content that helps us so much with our teams? I’m not sure I’ve got anything new for my teams from the content, it’s always been in my team 1.1 or 1.2 comment section, the videos are more or less just their opinion, which has proven to not exactly be worth of paying for. My opinion again.

The Chosen Won™®©
Member
Reply to  Matt

Last nights POD cast was like watching 3 fella’s talk footy without political correctness being an issues and it was pharking entertaining well worth the $2.50 a week!

Along with chances to win $500 or more!

Good Luck in 2023

Pine_Apple_Crush
Pine_Apple_Crush
1 year ago
Reply to  Matt

Well I mean anyone could do what the traders do really. Like its just that they put effort into writing up pieces and doing research that makes various selections seem viable.

Jett Harding
Jett Harding
1 year ago

This was my team from round 1
DEF – Doc (vc) , sicily , mcgrath , constable , ginbey , chesser (bench – cincotta , wilmot)
MID – Laird (C) , Brayshaw ,macrae , rozee , gulden , Ashcroft , Mackenzie , hollands (bench – mcvee , Johnston)
RUCK – English , marshall
FWD – Dunkley , Coniglio , toranto , sheezel , phillipou , greene (bench – laurie chandler)
Utility – long
Any thoughts on what I should do
was thinking putting mcgrath into midfeild and trading him to tom green

brian Smith
brian Smith
1 year ago
Reply to  Jett Harding

Fix your bench. Yes – Green > McGrath, but you need cash for the rest of the season. Cincotta, McVee, Johnston, Laurie, Long are earning you little to no cash. You’ll need to grab Uwland/Davey/Pedlar, maybe even Comben

Rizzard of Oz
Rizzard of Oz
1 year ago

Scored 2098
DEF: Doc, McGrath, Day, Constable, Ginbey, Cowan (Chesser, Wilmot)
MID: Macrae, Jelly, Green, Sheed, Worp, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Hollands (Philipou, Davey)
RUCK: Marshall, Witts (McAndrew)
FWD: Dunkley, Taranto, Cogs, Rozee, Gulden, Sheez (Greene, Pedlar)
(Long)
Jelly a hold? Will miss the easy matchup against West Coast obviously but should be back the week after. Is it worth trading Hollands early if it means I can get a superior rookie in Menzie in? My other trade is likely Greene to Chandler.

tommy
1 year ago

Hey boys, got a few options getting jelly and long out.

Horn Bag/Setterfield and worpel
Or
Chad Warner and Bytel/ Phillips

Cheers

jjbkeeper
jjbkeeper
1 year ago

Do we think Brennan Cox’ stats were good enough to consider bringing in @ D4. 30 disposals coming from 20 marks. Only one kick-in. Seems like a lot of intercept marks judging by his heat map.

JungleMuffin
Member
1 year ago
Reply to  jjbkeeper

No chance. Was entirely because Freo chipped the ball around, because St Kilda has Ross Lyon as a coach, and had the entire team sitting in St Kilda’s defensive half.

jjbkeeper
jjbkeeper
1 year ago
Reply to  JungleMuffin

Thanks for validating my thoughts.

Jarrod
Jarrod
1 year ago

Moving on Kelly and Sheed.

Would you go to Brayshaw and JHF – captaincy option / Uber premo and a breakout with fwd dpp or to Tom Green and Daicos – breakout and allows me to re-shuffle to field a second forward rook over Chesser / Cowan

Harry
Harry
1 year ago
Reply to  Jarrod

100% Green and Daicos, consider Hayden Young too… Green in my eyes will become a premo.

Izdizzle
Izdizzle
1 year ago

2110 ranked top 3000.

Do I trade Kelly or hold and fix up rooks.

Thinking Kelly to settleford

The Chosen Won™®©
Member
Reply to  Izdizzle

Trade Kelly then grab the lowest BE rookie, then that way you get a little of both worlds.

2017 CL Champion™®©
I smashed da Minj 2019 2020 2021 2022™®©
Good Luck in 2023™®©

Thrice
Thrice
1 year ago

Rank 22,000 giving out advice to rank 3,000. The Chosen Won continuing his form of being shithouse at fantasy haha

The Chosen Won™®©
Member
Reply to  Thrice

Me ole mate Twice cooked Hawk what can i say shit captain choice it will happen to you at some point you are lucky i didn’t get it right i would of beaten you ya pharking spider!

Now crawl back under your rock you spider!

I am Sam Hawk Menegola ™®©
Good Luck in 2023™®©

Baldrick's boys
Baldrick's boys
1 year ago
Reply to  Thrice

What a silly thing to say out loud, if I was ranked 2 would I only be able to get advice from no 1?

The Chosen Won™®©
Member

That’s his style, wait he doesn’t have any so he try’s to ride on my coat tales.

Good luck in 2023

The Chosen Won™®©
Member
Reply to  Thrice

I just checked your score you beat me by 120 and my captain score 57.

Good Luck in 2024

Baldrick's boys
Baldrick's boys
1 year ago

Sorry everyone – Kelly was my fault. I had a C on him, and seeing he was on 90 at 3 QTR time, thought I’d tune into watch the last QTR live…big fat mozz by me

The Chosen Won™®©
Member

My captain was chitter than your Captain :)) Good job on the win, See you in the finals!

Good Luck in 2023™®©

Squid
Squid
1 year ago

Kelly C here too, got a few rooks on field wrong, difference of 15k odd places to what could have been from the same team.

The point being luck plays a huge role in this game and someone’s round 1 rank doesn’t mean a great deal.

Also CW’s advice is normally pretty on point.

The Chosen Won™®©
Member
Reply to  Squid

Thanks Stu :))

Good Luck in 2023

Duckiez
Duckiez
1 year ago

I’ll be dropping J Kelly for Settlefield. Then Dropping J Hunt and bringing in N Blakey as I had a heap of cash in bank. Left with 61K

Duck
Duck
1 year ago

Not much difference in terms of total points between 30000 and 3000 at this stage, and Greg’s advice isn’t bad either. Cash generation important for the long term. And Settleford may even stink it up next week.

Ollie
Ollie
1 year ago

Score: 2033
Rank: 14,473
Def: Doc(C), Dawson, McGrath, Constable, Ginbey, Cowan (Wilmot, Bergman)
Mid: Laird, LDU, Sheed, Worpel, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Hollands (Phillipou, Chesser)
Ruck: Marshall, Witts (McBride)
Fwd: Dunks, Cogs, Taranto, Rozee, Gulden, Sheezel (Pedlar, Davey, Greene)

Thinking about going Laird to Tom Green and Chesser to Bytel. That gives me 133k to hopefully get Chandler next week possibly or go McGrath to Daicos if the rest goes to plan. Not too sure around Bytel’s job security but had around 14 cbas and I think and should hopefully be 70+ for the rest of the year. Any other thoughts greatly appreciated.

Dirty Birds
Dirty Birds
1 year ago
Reply to  Ollie

Waiting a week to grab Chandler will miss a ton of the cash generation. I don’t see him busting out a 100 too often, but I would go Chesser straight to Chandler and skip Bytel

Ando the brain dead barfly
Ando the brain dead barfly
1 year ago
Reply to  Dirty Birds

Bytel out this week with a leg cut

De Goaty
De Goaty
1 year ago

Def: Doch, Daicos, Mcgrath, Constable, Ginbey, Cowan (Wilmot, Chesser)
Mid: Bray, Bazlenka, De Goat, Sheed, Worpel, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie (Hollands, Davey)
Ruck: Marshall, Cameron (Mcandrew)
Fwd: Dunks, Taranto, Rozee, Gulden, Horne Francis, Sheezel (Pedlar, Long)
Utl: Phillipou
Generally lost on what to do apart from Long to chandler, kind of want green but can’t fit him in the midfield without sacrificing someone good.

JProeve
JProeve
1 year ago
Reply to  De Goaty

I have the exact same issue as you.. I want Green but would have to trade one of Macrae, Bont, or LDU for him which seems silly. I also can’t get enough cash to upgrade sheed to him, have you thought of that? We might have to fade Green for at least another round..

Dirty Birds
Dirty Birds
1 year ago

Score: 2059
Rank: 9895
Def: Doch, Stewart (Ouch), Day, Constable, Ginbey, Cowan (Wilmot, Uwland)
Mid: Brayshaw (C), Oliver, Green, Duursma, Worpel, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackensie (Hollands, Chesser)
Ruck: English, Marshall (McAndrew)
Fwd: Dunkley, Taranto, Rozee, Gulden, Flanders, Sheezel (Phillipou, Greene)
Util: (Laurie)
Happy with the score, especially considering the Stewart injury, but chasing too much mid-price madness has left me with only 8k in the bank. Regretting the 50/50 call with Laurie/Chandler last week. With little flexibility and a massive hole to fill I am considering Stewart to Chandler via some DPP magic for a massive cash grab, then Flanders to Naicos via some more DPP magic + 250k or Stewart to Naicos with Duursma to Chandler via DPP + 230k. Spewing I went for Duursma at the last minute to get myself into the bind and like Flanders match up this week so I’m leaning at keeping Flanders. Any thoughts or other options to consider appreciated :)

MitchW
MitchW
1 year ago

Score 1985. Thanks Lairdy!

Def: Doc, McGrath, Daicos, Constable, Chesser, Ginbey (McVee, Wilmot)

Mid: Laird, Steele, LDU, T.Greene, Callaghan, Ashcroft, Mackenzie, Uwland (Phillips, Long)

Ruck: Marshall, English (McAndrew)

Fwd: Dunk, Taranto, Coniglio, Gulden, Sheezel, Phillipou (Green, Laurie)
23k remaining.

I’m stuck with what to do. Every potential move seems to be too rash. Any ideas? Would love to upgrade long to Chandler. Considering downgrading McGrath to Cox to do that.

Rory
Rory
1 year ago

R1 score – 2088
Rank – 5791

Def – Doc, Duggan, Mcgrath, Richards, Constable, Ginbey (Wilmot, Bergman)

Mid – Dunks, Bont, LDU, Serong, Sheed, Worp, Ashcroft, McKenzie (Chesser, Uwland)

Ruck – Witts, Marshall (Heath)

Fwd- Taranto, Rozee, Gulden, Bruhn, Sheezel, L Henry (Pedlar, Greene)

(Davey)

4K left

Trades at the moment
– L Henry to Chandler
– Either Chesser (if dropped) or Greene to W Phillips (if named) or other option is Phillipou

BONTI04
BONTI04
1 year ago

score – 2120
rank – 2641

No injuries, no big problems either.

out: Titch, Fergus
in: Green, Chandler

poweyyy
poweyyy
1 year ago

SCORE – 1991
RANK – 24,520

(TEAM WITH MOVES AFTER ROUND 1)

DEF – Doc, McGrath, Day, Constable, Ginbey, Uwland (Wilmot, Chesser)

MID – Laird, Brayshaw, Macrae, Green, Worpel, Callaghan, Mackenzie, Ashcroft (Long, Phillipou)

RUCK – English, Marshall (Ryan)

FWD – Dunkley, Taranto, Rozee, Gulden, Sheezel, Chandler (Caminiti, Greene)

UTILITY – Davey

Got screwed over by Laird’s 57 as my captain (had brayshaw as my captain earlier but did a last-minute change, should’ve just taken Doc’s 110), Dunk’s not showing up, fielding Chesser over Uwland and not putting emergency on Chandler

I have already made the trade of Cowan > Worpel (had heaps of cash left as I made the last-minute decision of Kelly to Green, a literal life saver) and now just looking at possibly trading Laird (Royactionary I know) to one of the following – Oliver, LDU, Sic dog or another premo or possibly even a sneaky POD…

Another option is Mcgrath to Cox to free up my cash for next round trades… however that being said with the way St Kilda played on the weekend, McGrath could rack up a big score.

The only other option is changing N.Long or F.Greene to a new rookie.

Thoughts?

poweyyy
poweyyy
1 year ago
Reply to  poweyyy

Forgot to mention; after the Worpel trade, I have 18k in the bank

JProeve
JProeve
1 year ago

SCORE – 2105
RANK – 3,899

DEF – Doc, Daicos, Day, Constable, Ginbey, Chesser (Wilmot, Cowan)
MID – Macrae, Bont, LDU, Sheed, Worpel, Mackenzie, Ashcroft, Phillipou (Hollands, Davey)
RUCK – Marshall, Darcy (Heath)
FWD – Dunkley, Cogs, Taranto, Rozee, Gulden, Sheezel (Pedlar, Greene)
UTILITY – Long
$42k in bank..

Dodged all bullets fortunately. Keen to get Chandler and T Green in but I have no idea who do drop as I’m happy with all my picks..

Only options I can think of is downgrading one of Macrae, Bont, LDU to Green and then upgrading Long to Chandler. Does that sound stupid? Otherwise I think I have to miss out on Green.

poweyyy
poweyyy
1 year ago
Reply to  JProeve

Bont to Green looks like your best option here to me and then going long to chandler.

Ando the brain dead barfly
Ando the brain dead barfly
1 year ago
Reply to  poweyyy

Chandler should get more games after that effort even with troops returning




Recent Comments

Podcasts

Advertisement

More in My Team