Carlton AFL Fantasy Prices 2017

With each AFL Fantasy team price reveal, Peter from aflratings.com.au takes a look at five potential targets from each club.

Carlton improved team fantasy points in Brendon Bolton’s first year as head coach, the Blues were ranked 17th in 2015 averaging 1428.3pts and jumped to 13th in 2016 averaging 1550.7pt per game. There were significant individual opportunities at Carlton last year including Ed Curnow, Bryce Gibbs, Patrick Cripps & the backline duo in Kade Simpson and Sam Docherty. It will be a little more challenging to find value in 2017 as most seem to be appropriately priced at an expected average with the exception of Marc Murphy, once again the Blues turned over a significant amount of players in the trade period so pre-season games are a must watch to see how the new players fit in.

Carlton are likely to produce similar fantasy numbers in 2017, again they will be highly ranked in listed defenders and lowly ranked at the forward positions.

Here are 5 potential targets for Carlton in 2017

Sam Docherty (DEF, $609,000)

One of the most requested answers in fantasy last year was Docherty or Simpson, looking at their final player splits the only significant differential of note is the age of each player (Docherty 23 & Simpson 32). After averaging 82.2pts in 2015 Docherty relished his role around half back racking up disposals with ease, he finished the 2016 season averaging 25.7 Disposals and a 101.0 fantasy average. Most importantly as the Blues continue to rebuild Docherty averaged 102.0 in losing games, he should deliver another positive year as a backline option in 2017.

Kade Simpson (DEF, $611,000)

Despite getting on in age Simpson was a rock in defence last season averaging 101.1pts per game from a full season, Simpson is very durable having missed only 2 of a possible 95 games dating back to 2012. Simpson scored 100pts or more at a 54.5% S/R (Strike Rate) which was the same as Docherty, he finished the 2016 season off strong averaging 103.5pts between Rounds 12-23. At this point there is no wrong answer in the Simpson or Docherty debate, maybe even consider both in 2017.

Marc Murphy (MID, 482,000)

After another tortured year dealing with injury Marc Murphy’s durability is starting to become an issue for fantasy coaches, Murphy has played in only 74.2% of the 66 games available since the beginning of the 2014 season. There were a few positive indicators for Murphy in 2016 that proved he has not lost his fantasy scoring ability, he scored 100pts or more in his opening 6 games which included a season high 126pts against Richmond in Round 1. Opposition teams still tended to not allow Murphy to get of the chain in 2016, hopefully they will avoid him in 2017 and allow fantasy coaches taking the risk to be rewarded.

Sam Docherty of the Blues in action during the 2015 AFL Round 05 match between the Carlton Blues and the Collingwood Magpies at the MCG, Melbourne on May 01, 2015. (Photo: Michael Willson/AFL Media)

Bryce Gibbs (MID, $636,000)

Gibbs seemed to benefit from the close attention paid to Murphy by posting his highest season average since 2011, Gibbs averaged 105.4pts in 2016 which was an increase of 23.4pts compared to 2015. Gibbs jumped out early in 2016 averaging 112.5pts from his first 10 games, unfortunately Murphy was injured in Round 10 and Gibbs scored just 58 & 75 points in his next 2 games but recovered in his final 10 games to average 106.1pts. Gibbs scored 100pts or more at a 68.2% S/R (Top 10 AFL Rank) and 120pts or more at a 31.8% S/R, he should post similar numbers again in 2017.

Patrick Cripps (MID, $601,000)

Cripps is evolving in to a fairly decent fantasy option so early in his career, in just his 3rd year he posted a 99.5 average in a team that won just 6 games for the season. Whilst the moderate 33.3% S/R scoring 100pts or more wasn’t quite noteworthy in his final 7 games of the year Cripps averaged an outstanding 116.7pts which included a season high 140pts against Sydney in Round 18 at the SCG, Cripps was ranked 2nd in the AFL for average contested possessions (16.9) and a clear 1st in average clearances (8.8). Unfortunately Cripps is recovering from a stress reaction in his back that was revealed in late November, he is likely to resume full training in late January and with no more setbacks should be a strong consideration for any Round 1 team.

patrick-cripps


Click here to subscribe on iTunes.
Click here to download.

Note: If on a smartphone, turn it to landscape mode to view prices easier.

PlayerClubPos2016 Avg2016 Gms2017 Price
Gibbs, BryceCARMID105.4122$636000
Curnow, EdCARMID101.7621$614000
Simpson, KadeCARDEF101.1422$611000
Docherty, SamCARDEF10122$609000
Cripps, PatrickCARMID99.4821$601000
Wright, MatthewCARFWD84.3622$509000
Kerridge, SamCARMID80.3321$485000
Graham, NickCARMID/FWD80.3312$485000
Murphy, MarcCARMID79.810$482000
Thomas, DaleCARMID74.7818$451000
Kreuzer, MatthewCARRUC71.4821$431000
Palmer, RhysCARFWD6511$393000
Armfield, DennisCARFWD63.8715$385000
Byrne, CiaranCARDEF62.9111$380000
White, SimonCARDEF61.1217$369000
Buckley, DylanCARFWD57.8211$349000
Lamb, JedCARFWD57.615$348000
Weitering, JacobCARDEF57.420$347000
Gorringe, DanielCARRUC/FWD664$327000
Casboult, LeviCARFWD51.5520$311000
Boekhorst, BlaineCARMID/FWD55.577$305000
Silvagni, JackCARFWD53.388$303000
Silvagni, AlexCARDEF585$298000
Phillips, AndrewCARRUC49.4416$298000
Plowman, LachieCARDEF49.3219$298000
Jones, LiamCARFWD49.58$281000
Sumner, LiamCARFWD46.1916$278000
Cuningham, DavidCARMID553$262000
Smedts, BillieCARMID/FWD571$259000
Petrevski-Seton, SamCARMID00$240000
Curnow, CharlieCARFWD44.56$237000
Rowe, SamCARDEF38.4522$232000
Marchbank, CalebCARDEF44.52$205000
Jaksch, KristianCARDEF/FWD381$202000
Fisher, ZacCARMID00$198000
Macreadie, HarrisonCARDEF00$158000
Gallucci, AndrewCARFWD00$150000
Pickett, JarrodCARMID/FWD00$150000
Lebois, KymCARFWD00$150000
Sheehan, CiaranCARDEF00$150000
Polson, CameronCARFWD00$150000
Kerr, PatCARFWD00$150000
Williamson, TomCARDEF00$150000
Glass-McCasker, JesseCARDEF00$150000
McKay, HarryCARFWD00$150000
Korcheck, MatthewCARRUC00$150000

Follow @aflratings on Twitter and visit the website for more Fantasy.

4 Comments

  • Love the Crispter – my stats showed him warming up at end of season was a lock for me, but now will have to track pre season – but if fit round one hes in. At end of 2016 his 5 round avg was 113 as was his 3 round (H&A season)- he was only $536k but then so may have to revise his selection

  • Cripps ready by Jan? It’s been reported he won’t be back to full training loads until late Feb at the earliest… possibly early March.

    Murphy the interesting one here, reported to be in full training now. You can realistically expect a +12-15 point increase on last year’s average. Quick cash grab, then up to a premium.

    Whispers Weitering may be released forward with Marchbank’s arrival. Another that could potentially add 12-15 points on his 2016 average.

    • Think youd pick Murphy if you think he can go 100+ because Jaegar and Swallow can probably get those 90-95 avg and are far cheaper.

      • Agreed – although Murphy’s injury history is slightly more favourable. Jaeger is the most worrying out of those three. Patella injuries can be devastating. Still not sold on any of them until I see some game time.