Midfield Make-Up

This year there has been plenty of conversations around… what we as DT Coaches are doing with our midfield make-up for 2011.

Many people are going for the Gun/Rook strategy but others are saying they fancy the Gun, Mid-price man, rook approach…. which one are you?

NOTE: For the purpose of this discussion, lets call a rookie a dude that is priced under the 160k mark.

Gun, Gun, Gun, Gun… then roooooookies

These coaches are hitting hard early. Most likely have a Swan, Boyd, Montagna, Bartel or Ablett combo and then have the rookies filling the gaps. This is a solid approach but probably a little over board as they will have no money elsewhere to buy anyone of quality.

Gun, Gun, Gun… rooookies

A little more balanced, but probably still top heavy. This coach will certainly benefit from high scores early, but have they picked the top 3 guns? And will other coaches be able to snap up these players if they have a few bad games and drop in value.

Gun, Gun… roooookies

Wow, now we are nearly on the other side of the fence. This guy would have the Boyd/Swan combo and then have loaded up else where with rookies. The big question here is… will they find that many rookies who will be getting games on a regular basis.

Gun, Gun, Mid-Priced… roooookies

This guy is looking to either keep the MP or turn them into Ablett after he finishes his bye. Either way, it’s not a bad combo but a MP is risky. You’d be looking at Foley, McLean, Tambling and they are that 50/50 at the moment, it’s hard to call if they will hold together… if they even play.

Gun, Gun, Mid-Priced, Mid-Priced… rooooookies

Are you good enough to nail, 2 MP players? Wow… will be tough but if you know who they are and if you know they will kill it this year… go for it, a little risky in my book.

Gun… all roooookies

This guy has gone overboard so ignore the shit he’s dribbling to you, cause you’ll beat him easy!

So… what combo are you going with in your midfield at the moment.

Who will you have as your captain for Round 12?

  • Gary Ablett (65%, 1,650 Votes)
  • Dane Swan (28%, 702 Votes)
  • Scott Pendlebury (1%, 36 Votes)
  • Brent Stanton (3%, 70 Votes)
  • Jobe Watson (1%, 38 Votes)
  • Someone Else (2%, 53 Votes)

Total Voters: 2,549

Loading ... Loading ...

161 Comments

  • thanks mate!, yeah this method has worked for me in the past, and I tried going GUN GUN GUN GUN rookies last year and didn’t do as well. So I’m back to the ever reliable GUN GUN GUN rookie approach :D.

    In Terms of bank balance I’m still not sure, by Round 1 I will most likely have used the money somewhere (hopefully) but then again having that extra money may work in my favour.

  • Swan, Hodge, Murphy, Corey, Hannebery, Swallow

    G, G, G, G, MP/G, R………I’m sick of my team looking the same as everyone else so im going to change it up this year and see how I go!

  • Swan, Boyd, Selwood.J, Judd, Jack, Swallow – Gaff, Hibberd, Callinan

  • My midfield is likely to change 253 times before the opening bounce but at the moment it’s:

    Swan (G)
    A.Selwood, L.Anthony, R.Palmer,
    J.Blair
    Swallow, Libba, Wallis, Calinan

    Would really like to keep Blair in as I recon he’s only gonna get better but worried about two Pies in the midlfield.
    Any comments?

  • Swan, Boyd, Goddard, Selwood, Anthony, Gaff

    • Gun >$350,000
      Mid priced $160,000- $350,000
      Rookie <$160.00

      My side has – 13 guns, 4 mid priced, 5 rookies (Bench- all 11 rookies).

      • thats a bit contraversial, i think there is a difference in the price of a gun depending on position, for instance it might be 350k> for defenders and rucks but for the mids a gun would have to be over 400k IMO unless they are discounted like anthony

          • And i could have written a 9 page document on the definition of Gun, but i complied a guide in 3 lines, yes there is differences in what some under priced guns are at, and by saying $350,00 and over was a gun, it was a figure picked with Anthony in mind, the same way the original article states that a rook is anyone under $160,00 (Krakour/otten ain’t Rooks)

  • Guns: Swan, Boyd, Bartel
    MP/Gun: Jack
    The rest rooks.

    You gotta take a few risks with mid-priced players to win.
    I have Knights, Adcock, Petrie and Fraser as mine.
    Worst comes to worst I can downgrade them to a rook.
    Apart from Fraser, if they can remain injury free they can be keepers.

    • Mid priced really needs to be defined as experienced player who is under valued eg Petrie, Adcock, Knights, Krakouer, Harris, Fraser, Otten etc …. I think 4 under valued players is necessary just pick wisely

  • Gun,Gun,Gun, Mp (Cotchin) and rookies :d

  • I’ve gone with the gun, gun, gun, rookies approach
    Swan, Monty, Bartel, Swallow, Gaff, Mzunga with Harris, Heppell & Smith on the bench

  • Swan, Boyd, Bartel, Boak, Foley, Swallow (Harris, Smith, Hibberd)

  • Hayes or Montagna?
    plus should i save my $70, 500 salary cap left-over for upgrades?

  • Gun,Gun,Gun,Gun,Gun, Rookie is my set up

  • and still able to have a balanced team

  • swan, boyd, hodge, bartel, d.swallow, gaff

    or

    swan, , bartel, hodge, anthony, cotchin, swallow freeing up money for another forward gun

  • 2nd option

  • Giggedy, Giggedy… Gun, Gun, Gun, Gun, Harris, Rook, Rook, Rook, Rook!
    The way I see it, bloody lucky for us that Harris is so cheap!
    Could have easily been priced closer to Monty’s early FP, i think it was $176k.
    I am also of the opinion that Gun Fwds & Backs, can let you down more than the Gun mids.

  • is liam anthony MP or gun?

  • Gun, Gun, Gun, MidPrice, Rookie, Rookie (Rook, Rook, Rook)

    Swan, Montagna, Bartel, Dangerfield, Gaff, Mzungu (Harris, Hibberd, Schneider)

  • My midfield isswan, goddard, bartel, selwood, polec, d.harris

    subs= j.caddy, t.mzungugugugu, I.calinan

    thoughts??

    • You have to put Goddard in your backline, no questions asked.

      Reason: MIdfields are without a doubt the highest scoing players by position. Therefore, during the season you should aim to upgrade your midfield to the best six premium midfielders you can. So with your current set-up you will have something like this at seasons end: Swan, Ablett, Goddard, Bartel, Selwood, Montagna plus your backline.

      Now if you were to have Goddard in your backline you could get away with having say a Boyd or Pendlebury in you midfield replacing him, but also have him scoing in your backs. Technically you have 7 scoring midfields because without a doubt, Goddard will be the higest scoring defender again this season barring injury.

      Be careful of having both Bartel and Selwood as the Geelong bye will hurt your scoring assuming you probably have another player such as Chapman in your line-up. Look to swap Polec for Swallow, plainly because he should play every game this season and would average 20-30 points higher than Polec in my opinion.

  • Need to free up some coin
    Mids are Swan, Boyd, Montagna, Bartel, Harris, Swallow
    trade Swan to M Murphy
    Or Boyd/Montagna to L Anthony, only query is Anthony being injury prone

  • Got some spots to fill in this league 498528 get on it.

  • Gun Gun Gun. L Anthony. Rookie Rookie

    Anthony is considered mid price yes?

  • 5 guns, 2 mid-prices, 2 rooks.

    Swan, Boyd, Hodge, Bartel, Jack & Rich on the ground.
    Ward, Swallow & Wallis on the bench.

    Probably a bit too much $$$ on the pine, but I can’t find it in me to axe anyone.

  • Thoughts? M Boyd and P Contin as sub or anthor player for same price or L Hodge and R Conca. Rest of midfield is D Swan, L Montagna, L Anthony, D Swallow, A Gaff, J Polec and D Harris

  • 4 ‘Guns’ (priced 90-110) and 5 rookies.

  • Swan, Bartel, Boyd, Hodge, Anthony, Heppell (Polec, Harris, Mzungu).

    Could probably downgrade a Heppell or Polec to upgrade some others around the ground.

    Thoughts?

  • Middle is probably where you are going to make the most money, so I like the Gun/Gun/MP then rookies approach.

  • Swan, Boyd, Montagna Bartel with K.Jack + 4 rookies is my current setup. 15 keepers.

  • Swan, Montagna, Bartel, Stanton, Mzungu, Wallis (Swallow, Harris, Hibberd)

  • I’m going for the Gun, Gun, Gun, Rookie, Rookie, Rookie, (Rookie, Rookie, Rookie)

  • swan,pendels,bartel,boyd,swallow,harris,mzunga,atley,heppell

  • GUN, GUN, GUN, GUN, MP, ROOK, (ROOK, ROOK, ROOK)

    Swan, Boyd, Hayes, Bartel, Palmer, Mzunga (Swallow, Heppel, Harris)

  • Join the league if u want some competition 572121

  • Swan, Hayes, Selwood, Judd, Foley, Harris

    thats mine,

    what do u think?

  • Can someone tell me the results from the poll wont load for me

  • I cant believe how many people are overstacking their midfield with guns, but each to their own.

    A) Its like running a buisness, you have to make money to buy better products. As we ALL know, the most lucerative players are midfield players. If we take this piece of information the most lucerative rookies are going to be midfielders but if your midfield is full of guns where can you fit them in.

    B) You potentially risk loosing a huge amount of money if they dont perform, where we will be able to pick them up cheaply.

    C) You risk putting a sub-par Def and For on the field. Think about what position the rookies score the least points in. Thats where you dedicate some extra moolah…

    Hope this will be helpful for someone, but not to helpful :)